You have not yet responded to the forum.

Here you will find the last 3 forum topics
you have posted a comment on.
+ add shout
Sharonaa
I like my sootcase
0 | 0 | 0 | 0
0%
To join the forums you need to be logged in.

Click here to register your own account for free and I will personally explain to you how you can start getting your own fans and, making popdollars.
> Close
Helper
Forum
Startalk
Blog statistics
Friends management



Topics   Messages
10 of the 24 stars earned

Forum

Ideas < Virtual Popstar First | Previous | Page: | Next | Last
Poll: do you believe the teams are doing a fair job of choosing dress up comp winners?
Show results
objective ways to pick winners
Account deleted




wrote:
Claire wrote:
Nesta wrote:
Ainsley wrote:
tbh im not sure if that would be fair either; only for raffles
depends if the goal with the competition is to participate with a valid entry or to actually dress subjectively the best to a theme or with an item
i hate this lol.

if i want to play a raffle i'll play a raffle. dressup comps should be about skill dressing up.
skill more like if you have an available warderobe with good items
Date: 22-11-2019 23:50
Private
International star



Ainsley wrote:
if its really about skill for dressing up

what if we limited the wb accessibility?

like u could only use this ONE team member's wb to create the outfit? that would LITERALLY level the playing ground so much...!!
18
Posts: 10303
Date: 22-11-2019 23:51
Private
International star



Caramelia wrote:
Ainsley wrote:
if its really about skill for dressing up

what if we limited the wb accessibility?

like u could only use this ONE team member's wb to create the outfit? that would LITERALLY level the playing ground so much...!!
They've done that before. I liked it, but it was honestly just like all the other comps

The only way I can see how we could diversify the winners would be to have an item limit sometimes. That way the minimalistic outfits would have a chance. 
20
Posts: 7042
Date: 22-11-2019 23:52 | Times changed: 1
Private
World famous



Claire wrote:
Nesta wrote:
Claire wrote:
Nesta wrote:
depends if the goal with the competition is to participate with a valid entry or to actually dress subjectively the best to a theme or with an item
i hate this lol.

if i want to play a raffle i'll play a raffle. dressup comps should be about skill dressing up.
skill more like if you have an available warderobe with good items
but you're always allowed to use someoene else's wardrobe? use mine. 
21
Posts: 55674
Date: 22-11-2019 23:52
Private
World famous



Claire wrote:
i'd never tell anyone 'no' if they asked to use my wardrobe.
21
Posts: 55674
Date: 22-11-2019 23:52
Private
International star



Ainsley wrote:
Fayy wrote:
Ainsley wrote:
if its really about skill for dressing up

what if we limited the wb accessibility?

like u could only use this ONE team member's wb to create the outfit? that would LITERALLY level the playing ground so much...!!
They've done that before. I liked it, but it was honestly just like all the other comps
yea the style thing is still an issue!!

thats why the second part of my original post talked about diversifying the ways of winning.
18
Posts: 10303
Date: 22-11-2019 23:53
Parasite
World famous



Parasite wrote:
Ainsley wrote:
if its really about skill for dressing up

what if we limited the wb accessibility?

like u could only use this ONE team member's wb to create the outfit? that would LITERALLY level the playing ground so much...!!
That could be something to consider for ET's comps.
As for SMT, we've done some WWIB comps by having users style one fem or one male team member.
20
Posts: 10072
Date: 22-11-2019 23:53
Private
International star



Ainsley wrote:
Focalin wrote:
Ainsley wrote:
if its really about skill for dressing up

what if we limited the wb accessibility?

like u could only use this ONE team member's wb to create the outfit? that would LITERALLY level the playing ground so much...!!
That could be something to consider for ET's comps.
As for SMT, we've done some WWIB comps by having users style one fem or one male team member.
how did it work out? bc like i mentioned above i feel like the aesthetic thing would be an issue.
curious as to whether or not it was more accessible for others to win!
18
Posts: 10303
Date: 22-11-2019 23:54
Moss
National star



Moss wrote:
Ainsley wrote:
Focalin wrote:
Ainsley wrote:
if its really about skill for dressing up

what if we limited the wb accessibility?

like u could only use this ONE team member's wb to create the outfit? that would LITERALLY level the playing ground so much...!!
That could be something to consider for ET's comps.
As for SMT, we've done some WWIB comps by having users style one fem or one male team member.
how did it work out? bc like i mentioned above i feel like the aesthetic thing would be an issue.
curious as to whether or not it was more accessible for others to win!
A lot of people don't want to use another person's wd, and chose not to participate or show their dismay. And a lot of people liked it too! I mean, you can never please everyone 
15
Posts: 6746
Date: 22-11-2019 23:55
Private
International star



Ainsley wrote:
Moss wrote:
Ainsley wrote:
Focalin wrote:
That could be something to consider for ET's comps.
As for SMT, we've done some WWIB comps by having users style one fem or one male team member.
how did it work out? bc like i mentioned above i feel like the aesthetic thing would be an issue.
curious as to whether or not it was more accessible for others to win!
A lot of people don't want to use another person's wd, and chose not to participate or show their dismay. And a lot of people liked it too! I mean, you can never please everyone 
hm i can see how that would happen
i definitely would want to see the most amount of ppl pleased, which is why i had hoped this post would begin a conversation about how teams judge outfits/ran competitions

perhaps you could try to implement a mix of all these ideas just to try em out and see what kind of feedback you would get idk
18
Posts: 10303
Date: 22-11-2019 23:57
Moss
National star



Moss wrote:
Ainsley wrote:
Moss wrote:
Ainsley wrote:
how did it work out? bc like i mentioned above i feel like the aesthetic thing would be an issue.
curious as to whether or not it was more accessible for others to win!
A lot of people don't want to use another person's wd, and chose not to participate or show their dismay. And a lot of people liked it too! I mean, you can never please everyone 
hm i can see how that would happen
i definitely would want to see the most amount of ppl pleased, which is why i had hoped this post would begin a conversation about how teams judge outfits/ran competitions

perhaps you could try to implement a mix of all these ideas just to try em out and see what kind of feedback you would get idk
I definitely appreciate how you went about this! You raised the question in a very polite way and keep a nice conversation going, so thank you for that! I'm as interested in you in getting some better guidelines for the voting process so I'd be happy to discuss it within the team and come up with either some voting guidelines or more diverse WWIB themes that fit the more simple aesthetic too 
15
Posts: 6746
Date: 23-11-2019 00:01 | Times changed: 1
Private
International star



Ainsley wrote:
Moss wrote:
Ainsley wrote:
Moss wrote:
A lot of people don't want to use another person's wd, and chose not to participate or show their dismay. And a lot of people liked it too! I mean, you can never please everyone 
hm i can see how that would happen
i definitely would want to see the most amount of ppl pleased, which is why i had hoped this post would begin a conversation about how teams judge outfits/ran competitions

perhaps you could try to implement a mix of all these ideas just to try em out and see what kind of feedback you would get idk
I definitely appreciate how you went about this! You raised the question in a very polite way and keep a nice conversation going, so thank you for that! I'm as interested in you in getting some better guidelines for the voting process so I'd be happy to discuss it within the team and some up with either voting rules or more diverse WWIB themes that fit the more simple aesthetic too 
no, thank you for being so respectful of my opinion! was a bit worried about how some team members would react to this, but i'm glad i was able to raise awareness on this issue, and that you will continue it within your team! can't wait to see some steps towards the right direction!!~
18
Posts: 10303
Date: 23-11-2019 00:04
Parasite
World famous



Parasite wrote:
Ainsley wrote:
Moss wrote:
Ainsley wrote:
hm i can see how that would happen
i definitely would want to see the most amount of ppl pleased, which is why i had hoped this post would begin a conversation about how teams judge outfits/ran competitions

perhaps you could try to implement a mix of all these ideas just to try em out and see what kind of feedback you would get idk
I definitely appreciate how you went about this! You raised the question in a very polite way and keep a nice conversation going, so thank you for that! I'm as interested in you in getting some better guidelines for the voting process so I'd be happy to discuss it within the team and some up with either voting rules or more diverse WWIB themes that fit the more simple aesthetic too 
no, thank you for being so respectful of my opinion! was a bit worried about how some team members would react to this, but i'm glad i was able to raise awareness on this issue, and that you will continue it within your team! can't wait to see some steps towards the right direction!!~
I 2nd what Moss said. 
Even if we don't agree with it (which I don't think is really the case here) we appreciate people presenting their criticisms or ideas in a polite way.
20
Posts: 10072
Date: 23-11-2019 00:09
Private
International star



Ainsley wrote:
Focalin wrote:
Ainsley wrote:
Moss wrote:
I definitely appreciate how you went about this! You raised the question in a very polite way and keep a nice conversation going, so thank you for that! I'm as interested in you in getting some better guidelines for the voting process so I'd be happy to discuss it within the team and some up with either voting rules or more diverse WWIB themes that fit the more simple aesthetic too 
no, thank you for being so respectful of my opinion! was a bit worried about how some team members would react to this, but i'm glad i was able to raise awareness on this issue, and that you will continue it within your team! can't wait to see some steps towards the right direction!!~
I 2nd what Moss said. 
Even if we don't agree with it (which I don't think is really the case here) we appreciate people presenting their criticisms or ideas in a polite way.
happy we're on the same page!
18
Posts: 10303
Date: 23-11-2019 00:14
Gravitation
World famous



Gravitation wrote:
Eis wrote:
i agree with all of this

tbh most of the time i think what they rly base it on is how much they like you as a person, no matter how good ur outfit was or not
like i feel there's an unfairness going on

but also one idea could maybe be that everyone would send in their outfits, i'm thinking like a separate website, and it all is done anonymous so they can't see what user sent in what
THEN they (the team) do their own voting thing and vote according to the theme etc etc
for some reason i think that would make the winners for each comp more varied? if that makes sense
since they would have no ability of knowing which users it's from unless they're an expert at telling which outfit was made by which user
Idk about anyone else obviously, but I couldn't care less who the people are that I'm voting for. Not that I really dislike anyone anyway lmao, but even if there were a person I HATED I would still vote for them if I think their outfit was one of the best imo! 

What I base my voting on is things like color combo (how well it's coordinated), details, the overall look, how well it fits the theme, how unique it is etc {option}
21
Posts: 5388
Date: 23-11-2019 00:33
Post comment
Post Comment
To load new posts: activated
First | Previous | Page: | Next | Last
© 2024 Terms of Use