You have not yet responded to the forum.

Here you will find the last 3 forum topics
you have posted a comment on.
0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0
0%
+ add shout
Meister
R U =0)
To join the forums you need to be logged in.

Click here to register your own account for free and I will personally explain to you how you can start getting your own fans and, making popdollars.
> Close
Helper
19 of the 24 stars earned

Forum

General < General Page: | Next | Last
The Bechdel Test
Persona
Streetmusician



do you feel it's a useful way to point out gender inequality in fiction? do you think it's a good indicator of a feminist film/book? or not?

Bechdel Test: "The test has primarily been applied to film and also fiction.The test asks the consumer/user to determine two aspects of the creative work: 1) at least two women who talk to each other, 2) about something other than a man. The test sometimes adds that the two women must be named characters"
Account deleted




I mean I would say that it's not strict enough/the requirements aren't hard enough but considering that to this day in 20 fucking 20 mainstream movies and episodes of TV shows don't pass it says everything that needs to be said imo
Account deleted




Lotr lmaoo
Private
World Famous



i don't think it necessarily indicates that it's a feminist film/book, but it's definitely a good starting point (:
Persona
Streetmusician



another question would be: what makes a film/tv show/novel feminist?  to me this is SUCH a difficult question to answer and tbh i don't think there is a definitive answer
Private
International Star



I find it alarming when you have entire franchises with a female main character that doesn't pass that, it shouldn't be hard but yet
Alam
World Famous



The fact that there are so many films and tv shows that do't pass it is crazy to me, it shouldn't be that hard, you should be doing it accidentally.
Grovyle
Streetmusician



i dont think passing the bechdel test is enough constitute a feminist piece of media. 

i think something actively constituting as a feminist piece of media is v different to something just passing as having a vague feminist message. i feel like the latter could be done just by having a host of 3D female characters inc. queer and POC characters that are properly fleshed out (including passing the bechdel test)

but then to make something that's actively feminist . man idk 
it would have to have some kind of political element i guess ???
Account deleted




Persona wrote:
another question would be: what makes a film/tv show/novel feminist?  to me this is SUCH a difficult question to answer and tbh i don't think there is a definitive answer

my personal test:
i don't feel brain dead after watching it
Private
World Famous



To point out gender inequality? Yes. Because apparently it's very hard to create fiction that can't even pass such simple requirements...

To judge whether it's feminist? Absolutely not. To claim that a piece of fiction is feminist just because there are two women talking about something else than men is setting the bar way too low.
Private
World Famous



Persona wrote:
another question would be: what makes a film/tv show/novel feminist?  to me this is SUCH a difficult question to answer and tbh i don't think there is a definitive answer
For starters, it shouldn't portray women with a male gaze (or have a hegemonic masculinity perspective in its portrayal of events), and it shouldn't perpetuate stereotypes. 
Persona
Streetmusician



BloomCissi wrote:
Persona wrote:
another question would be: what makes a film/tv show/novel feminist?  to me this is SUCH a difficult question to answer and tbh i don't think there is a definitive answer
For starters, it shouldn't portray women with a male gaze (or have a hegemonic masculinity perspective in its portrayal of events), and it shouldn't perpetuate stereotypes. 
hmmmm interesting. can you think of some examples?
Private
World Famous



Persona wrote:
BloomCissi wrote:
Persona wrote:
another question would be: what makes a film/tv show/novel feminist?  to me this is SUCH a difficult question to answer and tbh i don't think there is a definitive answer
For starters, it shouldn't portray women with a male gaze (or have a hegemonic masculinity perspective in its portrayal of events), and it shouldn't perpetuate stereotypes. 
hmmmm interesting. can you think of some examples?
Unfortunately not, because I don't watch movies, barely read books and rarely watch series... 
Private
World Famous



BloomCissi wrote:
Persona wrote:
BloomCissi wrote:
For starters, it shouldn't portray women with a male gaze (or have a hegemonic masculinity perspective in its portrayal of events), and it shouldn't perpetuate stereotypes. 
hmmmm interesting. can you think of some examples?
Unfortunately not, because I don't watch movies, barely read books and rarely watch series... 
but also there literally are not many examples. even a lot of female directed movies are shot with a male gaze somehow lmao.

here's an essay i wrote in college about the male gaze using ghostbusters (2016) as an example https://docs.google.com/document/d/1zTeCiK6ZnPCRJqKmBpPSHnHzjBkZb73MVVIiMU_mUlg/edit?usp=sharing you might like this
Private
World Famous



for a film to be feminist i think it should subvert our expectations of gender. something like Kill Bill is feminist because The Bride is a major badass in a way we don't expect of women. Frozen is feminist because princessees aren't saved by men like we would expect from princesses in a disney movie. 
Private
World Famous



i mean there's more than one way to look at it. 

and then when did the movie come out that's gonna effect our viewing of it. i'm not going to hold a 1950s film to a 2020s standard of 'feminist'
Post comment
Post Comment
To load new posts: activated
Page: | Next | Last