You have not yet responded to the forum.

Here you will find the last 3 forum topics
you have posted a comment on.
0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0
0%
+ add shout
Private
send me wl :3
To join the forums you need to be logged in.

Click here to register your own account for free and I will personally explain to you how you can start getting your own fans and, making popdollars.
> Close
Helper
13 of the 24 stars earned

Forum

General < General First | Previous | Page: | Next | Last
Genders
Private
Popstar



mikkelrev wrote:
ouch wrote:
Azriel wrote:
Im not sure what to think about the transwomen in sports thing bc on one hand theyre women so like they belong there but on the other hand they do have an unfair advantage
As long as you have gone through male puberty, you should not be allowed to compete alongside biological women
u wont get any testosterone based advantages if ur on blockers and/or (cant remember) taking estrogen tho like. ur just more likely to be taller than the other women on the team
Bones, muscles etc are different from a male body to a female one, as long as they have gone through puberty, blockers and estrogen will not change that 
Private
International Star



ouch wrote:
mikkelrev wrote:
ouch wrote:
As long as you have gone through male puberty, you should not be allowed to compete alongside biological women
u wont get any testosterone based advantages if ur on blockers and/or (cant remember) taking estrogen tho like. ur just more likely to be taller than the other women on the team
Bones, muscles etc are different from a male body to a female one, as long as they have gone through puberty, blockers and estrogen will not change that 
i dunno that is not the lived experience of anyone ive talked about this with
maybe there is some maybe there isnt but pro athletes work out like weirdos anyway so like. they can kick anyones ass anyway

sports should be split up into skill/strength classes regardless of gender/sex/whatever the fuck anyway
Private
Popstar



mikkelrev wrote:
Rainstorm wrote:
mikkelrev wrote:
again?


anyway i think everything is fake and made up so we should just be nice okay. dont be a dick. aint hard
Again? :-O

Being "nice" can be such a grey area though.. What one person consider "nice", isn't necessarily what the other person sees as well

I can play the devil's advocate here and argue that letting trans-women compete in women's sports is nice for the trans-women, but is it "nice" for the biological women who might be at a disadvantage when competing with men? "You lose" whichever side you're on. Somebody always ends up getting hurt so unfortunately it's not always as easy as "just being nice" :-/
its just a thing that gets brought up somewhat frequently and someones always a dick about it when it happens

on the other hand should we even split sport into genders to begin with like what the fuck
I know these type of subjects can be sensitive... :-/ if somebody's being rude or inappropriate, I think it's for the better just to ignore them and not ruin the discussion for everyone else. I mean there's not much else to do about it lol

I guess it would be too male dominated since (biological) males are usually a lot stronger and faster than (biological) women. Women wouldn't really have the chance to become professionals in sports
Private
Popstar



I think it was Serena Williams that said it herself that even though she's one of the top female tennis players, her skills doesn't compare even to non-professional male tennis players. Biological men and biological women are just built different like that :-/
Private
Popstar



mikkelrev wrote:
ouch wrote:
mikkelrev wrote:
u wont get any testosterone based advantages if ur on blockers and/or (cant remember) taking estrogen tho like. ur just more likely to be taller than the other women on the team
Bones, muscles etc are different from a male body to a female one, as long as they have gone through puberty, blockers and estrogen will not change that 
X
i dunno that is not the lived experience of anyone ive talked about this with
maybe there is some maybe there isnt but pro athletes work out like weirdos anyway so like. they can kick anyones ass anyway

sports should be split up into skill/strength classes regardless of gender/sex/whatever the fuck anyway
Sports are currently divided into gender and height/weight class. Mens muscles just work better and use oxygen better than women muscles, so if it was just divided into height/weight, a man or trans women would still have an advantage over a cis female. That's just how our bodies work. That's why men run faster and are generally stronger than females. 
Height, hand size, arm length etc etc also has a say in a lot of sports, making that also generally an unfair advantage.

I guess the best is to divide it into strength and height, but its hard to measure strength like that, making it best if you are not allowed to compete against someone not of your biological gender.
MasileinDE
International Star



just going to write about the bathrooms

I honestly would LOVE genderneutral bathrooms
that's basically one bathroom with different toilet stalls and then just logos on the doors if it's a toilet behind or a urinal
end then shared washroom and such

I've been to a few of those lately and let's just say: they have by far been the cleanest bathrooms I've ever been to and it's not even weird
(though to be fair, I don't feel threatened or a shamed by much, I don't care if a man hears me poop in the stall next door)
Private
Popstar



Rainstorm wrote:
I think it was Serena Williams that said it herself that even though she's one of the top female tennis players, her skills doesn't compare even to non-professional male tennis players. Biological men and biological women are just built different like that :-/
Yeah, there has also been a lot of trans women switching over to the bio female side, and beating a lot of the world records. It isnt fair 
MasileinDE
International Star



ouch wrote:
Rainstorm wrote:
I think it was Serena Williams that said it herself that even though she's one of the top female tennis players, her skills doesn't compare even to non-professional male tennis players. Biological men and biological women are just built different like that :-/
Yeah, there has also been a lot of trans women switching over to the bio female side, and beating a lot of the world records. It isnt fair 

jups

this might change when we'll be seeing more transgender people participating in their new (? I'm not the best when it comes to the proper nterminology) gender and they've been in transition since puberty
of course the structure will still be the same, but due to the different hormones and the early beginning of the hormonal treatment, the body will develop differently and it might be more balanced than it seems now
Private
International Star



ouch wrote:
mikkelrev wrote:
ouch wrote:
Bones, muscles etc are different from a male body to a female one, as long as they have gone through puberty, blockers and estrogen will not change that 
X
i dunno that is not the lived experience of anyone ive talked about this with
maybe there is some maybe there isnt but pro athletes work out like weirdos anyway so like. they can kick anyones ass anyway

sports should be split up into skill/strength classes regardless of gender/sex/whatever the fuck anyway
Sports are currently divided into gender and height/weight class. Mens muscles just work better and use oxygen better than women muscles, so if it was just divided into height/weight, a man or trans women would still have an advantage over a cis female. That's just how our bodies work. That's why men run faster and are generally stronger than females. 
Height, hand size, arm length etc etc also has a say in a lot of sports, making that also generally an unfair advantage.

I guess the best is to divide it into strength and height, but its hard to measure strength like that, making it best if you are not allowed to compete against someone not of your biological gender.

two ppl who can bench press a horse are two people who can bench press a horse, what more categorization do they need

dividing it into sex and like, weight or height makes no sense either, women have different body shapes from other women like. i had twice the leg power of any girl on my teams or opposing teams so by all means that was unfair, yet there i was, plowing people down like a wild giraffe because we were all chicks of the same approximate age so its fair right

i dunno i think its dumb. what hormone flows thru ur body is far from the only factor that decides how good u are at sports. i have beef with gender in general i am biased
Private
Popstar



MasileinDE wrote:
ouch wrote:
Rainstorm wrote:
I think it was Serena Williams that said it herself that even though she's one of the top female tennis players, her skills doesn't compare even to non-professional male tennis players. Biological men and biological women are just built different like that :-/
Yeah, there has also been a lot of trans women switching over to the bio female side, and beating a lot of the world records. It isnt fair 

jups

this might change when we'll be seeing more transgender people participating in their new (? I'm not the best when it comes to the proper nterminology) gender and they've been in transition since puberty
of course the structure will still be the same, but due to the different hormones and the early beginning of the hormonal treatment, the body will develop differently and it might be more balanced than it seems now
Yeah,thats why I said u should not be allowed if you have gone through male puberty. As long as you started very early on it should probably be ok
Private
Popstar



mikkelrev wrote:
ouch wrote:
mikkelrev wrote:
i dunno that is not the lived experience of anyone ive talked about this with
maybe there is some maybe there isnt but pro athletes work out like weirdos anyway so like. they can kick anyones ass anyway

sports should be split up into skill/strength classes regardless of gender/sex/whatever the fuck anyway
Sports are currently divided into gender and height/weight class. Mens muscles just work better and use oxygen better than women muscles, so if it was just divided into height/weight, a man or trans women would still have an advantage over a cis female. That's just how our bodies work. That's why men run faster and are generally stronger than females. 
Height, hand size, arm length etc etc also has a say in a lot of sports, making that also generally an unfair advantage.

I guess the best is to divide it into strength and height, but its hard to measure strength like that, making it best if you are not allowed to compete against someone not of your biological gender.

two ppl who can bench press a horse are two people who can bench press a horse, what more categorization do they need

dividing it into sex and like, weight or height makes no sense either, women have different body shapes from other women like. i had twice the leg power of any girl on my teams or opposing teams so by all means that was unfair, yet there i was, plowing people down like a wild giraffe because we were all chicks of the same approximate age so its fair right

i dunno i think its dumb. what hormone flows thru ur body is far from the only factor that decides how good u are at sports. i have beef with gender in general i am biased
You wasnt in professional sports tho I assume? There is a big difference. When you are 18+ most bodies should be around the same strength if you are the same height and weight (and do professional sport ofc)
MasileinDE
International Star



mikkelrev wrote:
ouch wrote:
mikkelrev wrote:
i dunno that is not the lived experience of anyone ive talked about this with
maybe there is some maybe there isnt but pro athletes work out like weirdos anyway so like. they can kick anyones ass anyway

sports should be split up into skill/strength classes regardless of gender/sex/whatever the fuck anyway
Sports are currently divided into gender and height/weight class. Mens muscles just work better and use oxygen better than women muscles, so if it was just divided into height/weight, a man or trans women would still have an advantage over a cis female. That's just how our bodies work. That's why men run faster and are generally stronger than females. 
Height, hand size, arm length etc etc also has a say in a lot of sports, making that also generally an unfair advantage.

I guess the best is to divide it into strength and height, but its hard to measure strength like that, making it best if you are not allowed to compete against someone not of your biological gender.

two ppl who can bench press a horse are two people who can bench press a horse, what more categorization do they need

dividing it into sex and like, weight or height makes no sense either, women have different body shapes from other women like. i had twice the leg power of any girl on my teams or opposing teams so by all means that was unfair, yet there i was, plowing people down like a wild giraffe because we were all chicks of the same approximate age so its fair right

i dunno i think its dumb. what hormone flows thru ur body is far from the only factor that decides how good u are at sports. i have beef with gender in general i am biased

there is a difference between being good at sports and competing at a professional level

plus, the whole biology thing: there are studies that show that biological women and men have very different muscle tissue. it's got a completely different structure

the thing with professional athletes is that they from really young train certain muscles or muscle grous and abilities to be better at that specific sport. even when you look at all the women, they wouldn't all be "perfect" on a purely biological level to be professional runners. but comparing perfect male runners to perfect female runners, you can see that males in general are far stronger than women. on the other hand, women tend to be more agile and quick (just take a look at gymnasts).
[when using male and female here, I'm referring to biological women and men]
Private
International Star



ouch wrote:
mikkelrev wrote:
ouch wrote:
Sports are currently divided into gender and height/weight class. Mens muscles just work better and use oxygen better than women muscles, so if it was just divided into height/weight, a man or trans women would still have an advantage over a cis female. That's just how our bodies work. That's why men run faster and are generally stronger than females. 
Height, hand size, arm length etc etc also has a say in a lot of sports, making that also generally an unfair advantage.

I guess the best is to divide it into strength and height, but its hard to measure strength like that, making it best if you are not allowed to compete against someone not of your biological gender.

two ppl who can bench press a horse are two people who can bench press a horse, what more categorization do they need

dividing it into sex and like, weight or height makes no sense either, women have different body shapes from other women like. i had twice the leg power of any girl on my teams or opposing teams so by all means that was unfair, yet there i was, plowing people down like a wild giraffe because we were all chicks of the same approximate age so its fair right

i dunno i think its dumb. what hormone flows thru ur body is far from the only factor that decides how good u are at sports. i have beef with gender in general i am biased
You wasnt in professional sports tho I assume? There is a big difference. When you are 18+ most bodies should be around the same strength if you are the same height and weight (and do professional sport ofc)
not professional as in aired on tv take ur bets pro, but it was serious sport(s)
the human body varies so fucking much, i do not see the fairness in having the biggest deciding factor be sex. i really dont. football is skill and stamina, ive seen women beat the ever living shit out of equally trained men on the field weekly through a large portion of my childhood

im not denying a difference in biology, but i dont think that two people who can both do the exact same thing should be barred from doing so bc their genitals dont match. the weight classes, strength classes, height, whichever ones are the qualifying ones for a given sport, they keep things even, and i dont see why sex should be one of them on top of it all
callum
World Famous



gender neutral bathrooms yup, tired of standing outside the toilet waiting for my girlies 
MasileinDE
International Star



mikkelrev wrote:
ouch wrote:
mikkelrev wrote:

two ppl who can bench press a horse are two people who can bench press a horse, what more categorization do they need

dividing it into sex and like, weight or height makes no sense either, women have different body shapes from other women like. i had twice the leg power of any girl on my teams or opposing teams so by all means that was unfair, yet there i was, plowing people down like a wild giraffe because we were all chicks of the same approximate age so its fair right

i dunno i think its dumb. what hormone flows thru ur body is far from the only factor that decides how good u are at sports. i have beef with gender in general i am biased
You wasnt in professional sports tho I assume? There is a big difference. When you are 18+ most bodies should be around the same strength if you are the same height and weight (and do professional sport ofc)
not professional as in aired on tv take ur bets pro, but it was serious sport(s)
the human body varies so fucking much, i do not see the fairness in having the biggest deciding factor be sex. i really dont. football is skill and stamina, ive seen women beat the ever living shit out of equally trained men on the field weekly through a large portion of my childhood

im not denying a difference in biology, but i dont think that two people who can both do the exact same thing should be barred from doing so bc their genitals dont match. the weight classes, strength classes, height, whichever ones are the qualifying ones for a given sport, they keep things even, and i dont see why sex should be one of them on top of it all

there have been studies about this that explain what ouch and I are trying to tell you
of course eople can compare when it comes to sports that need a mixture of different specialties
but if you for instance just compare pure force, the top will always be men, no matter how hard you root for the females
the difference isn't just in the gentials, it's so much more and denying that just makes you super ignorant
Post comment
Post Comment
To load new posts: activated
First | Previous | Page: | Next | Last