You have not yet responded to the forum.

Here you will find the last 3 forum topics
you have posted a comment on.
0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0
0%
+ add shout
Meister
R U =0)
To join the forums you need to be logged in.

Click here to register your own account for free and I will personally explain to you how you can start getting your own fans and, making popdollars.
> Close
Helper
14 of the 24 stars earned

Forum

General < General First | Previous | Page: | Next | Last
vegan debate
Private
National Star



Homer wrote:
kagura wrote:
Homer wrote:
what do u think about rats or squirrels that r considred pest animals?
very good question actually, bc they really can be harmfull in farms etc. i was working on this old ranch last summer and they had these things that caught rats inside them and made them unconscious.. but i actually have no idea what happened to them afterwards, there wasn't any rats during my time there
but the point was not killing them so yea i guess you can get rid off them without killing
is it possible to get rid of them "humanely" w/o killing them in large quantities? idk about that
well that i do not know
Homer
Streetmusician



kagura wrote:
Homer wrote:
kagura wrote:
very good question actually, bc they really can be harmfull in farms etc. i was working on this old ranch last summer and they had these things that caught rats inside them and made them unconscious.. but i actually have no idea what happened to them afterwards, there wasn't any rats during my time there
but the point was not killing them so yea i guess you can get rid off them without killing
is it possible to get rid of them "humanely" w/o killing them in large quantities? idk about that
well that i do not know
idk either. i dont think its possibel though
Account deleted




Specter wrote:
Homer wrote:
bones wrote:
you cant eat or consume anything and fight for animal rights without being a hypocrite of some kind bcs unless you grow every single thing yourself, someone along the line suffers anyway
eating meat doesnt make you a bad person
no diet can make you a bad person
everyone has to eat
u think cannibalism is morally acceptable even if it's not necessary for survival?

(reposting bc i quoted the wrong post)

^
first off don't be a smartass , you seem to really like nitpicking in discussions like these whenever you can't come up with a valid point.

that said, almost all agriculture is founded on slave labor. since you want to bring up veganism specifically, quinoa (a staple of almost all vegan diets) is being farmed and exported en masse, when it was once a staple of bolivian diets. on top of taking food from indigenous people, the demand for it has resulted in the soil that it was once sustainably grown on becoming stripped of its minerals, meaning it's only increasingly harder to grow other things there. how about the trend of pet owners that try to feed their pets a vegan diet? should vegans be allowed to have pets since they require meat?

back to the main point, obviously the food industry needs reform, let's start with having companies be totally unable to patent plants. let's talk about how coca-cola had hired assassins kill workers that were attempting to unionize.

if you want to go the 'animals dying' route, consider that vegan diets actually kill more animals than a meat-consuming diet, it's just smaller animals like mice, worms, and birds. by your standards, those animals should mean just as much as cattle, right?

unless you are literally growing your own food, which is impossible for the modern person to do thanks to a combination of lack of land, landlords not giving permission, and the modern workday schedule, then you can't assume that a vegan diet is going to fix everything, let alone negate the effects of 'animal cruelty'. literally everything and anything you do is going to result in an animal death.
not here to argue but, it's important to differentiate the fact that animals such as cats are obligate carnivores, meaning they can't be vegan and making them vegan is BAD. it's sad sure but it's necessary. or, even better, pick a pet that doesn't require meat in it's diet.

as for us, humans, science advanced enough to the point where we don't have to kill an animal to live (healthly). we can't make lions eat supplements but we surley can do, it's so easy and hella easy compared to killing an animal from start to finish

and if veganism is doing damage for the environment, it can't be worse than the meat industry. pick the worse of two ?
Account deleted




Homer wrote:
Nesta wrote:
Homer wrote:
it's easier to argue if you just pick and choose on what you want to reply to, isn't it
I wasn't even arguing. I was answering your question on the basis of what I've asked before and witnessed as the result, then you ask me a question about me personally - or one on the basis of the earlier experience - and I can't answer it because I can't represent it so shutting up is clever sometimes 
but u said it's unethical to harm animals if there's no need, n vegans care about insects, so how would u feel about killing cockroaches? i don't get why u can't answer that

but some animals are harmful. if u can't get it safely outside then the only option is to kill it or end up with an insect in your face
Private
National Star



Pavlov wrote:
Homer wrote:
kagura wrote:
very good question actually, bc they really can be harmfull in farms etc. i was working on this old ranch last summer and they had these things that caught rats inside them and made them unconscious.. but i actually have no idea what happened to them afterwards, there wasn't any rats during my time there
but the point was not killing them so yea i guess you can get rid off them without killing
is it possible to get rid of them "humanely" w/o killing them in large quantities? idk about that
whats wrong with killing an animal, theyre gonna die eventually, i think the inhumane part of the meat industry is the way they keep the animals alive, if you can kill something without making it suffer then youve already succeeded
you're right about meat industry, but that's kinda bad argument. all humans are going to die eventually too
Pavlov
International Star



kagura wrote:
Pavlov wrote:
Homer wrote:
is it possible to get rid of them "humanely" w/o killing them in large quantities? idk about that
whats wrong with killing an animal, theyre gonna die eventually, i think the inhumane part of the meat industry is the way they keep the animals alive, if you can kill something without making it suffer then youve already succeeded
you're right about meat industry, but that's kinda bad argument. all humans are going to die eventually too
humans and animals are two completely different things
Pavlov
International Star



Pavlov wrote:
kagura wrote:
Pavlov wrote:
whats wrong with killing an animal, theyre gonna die eventually, i think the inhumane part of the meat industry is the way they keep the animals alive, if you can kill something without making it suffer then youve already succeeded
you're right about meat industry, but that's kinda bad argument. all humans are going to die eventually too
humans and animals are two completely different things
if your argument was to work we would have to live by the same laws as animals, that would mean that either we would be allowed to murder and eat eachother or animals would have to start shopping on walmart
Account deleted




Pavlov wrote:
kagura wrote:
Pavlov wrote:
whats wrong with killing an animal, theyre gonna die eventually, i think the inhumane part of the meat industry is the way they keep the animals alive, if you can kill something without making it suffer then youve already succeeded
you're right about meat industry, but that's kinda bad argument. all humans are going to die eventually too
humans and animals are two completely different things

why ? sure they can be dumb as rocks but intelligence is not why we have empathy for other things/people. that would be fucked up. and believe me, they do feel emotions, at least some of them i can be sure
Private
National Star



Pavlov wrote:
Pavlov wrote:
kagura wrote:
you're right about meat industry, but that's kinda bad argument. all humans are going to die eventually too
humans and animals are two completely different things
if your arguement was to work we would have to live by the same laws as animals, that would mean that either we would be allowed to murder and eat eachother or animals would have to start shopping on walmart
i have no problem with animals shopping at walmart

yes of course we're different from other animals. but we both have same basics needs and emotions. no animal wants to die so it's not okay to kill them for fun.
Homer
Streetmusician



Ruee wrote:
Pavlov wrote:
kagura wrote:
you're right about meat industry, but that's kinda bad argument. all humans are going to die eventually too
humans and animals are two completely different things

why ? sure they can be dumb as rocks but intelligence is not why we have empathy for other things/people. that would be fucked up. and believe me, they do feel emotions, at least some of them i can be sure
that's fucked
Pavlov
International Star



kagura wrote:
Pavlov wrote:
Pavlov wrote:
humans and animals are two completely different things
if your arguement was to work we would have to live by the same laws as animals, that would mean that either we would be allowed to murder and eat eachother or animals would have to start shopping on walmart
i have no problem with animals shopping at walmart

yes of course we're different from other animals. but we both have same basics needs and emotions. no animal wants to die so it's not okay to kill them for fun.
making animals not live by their natural instincts would be animal abuse, and nobody is talking about killing them for fun
Pavlov
International Star



Pavlov wrote:
kagura wrote:
Pavlov wrote:
if your arguement was to work we would have to live by the same laws as animals, that would mean that either we would be allowed to murder and eat eachother or animals would have to start shopping on walmart
i have no problem with animals shopping at walmart

yes of course we're different from other animals. but we both have same basics needs and emotions. no animal wants to die so it's not okay to kill them for fun.
making animals not live by their natural instincts would be animal abuse, and nobody is talking about killing them for fun
we just have to live with the fact that in nature animals get culled, we shouldnt feel bad for killing them either, we should just make sure we dont make them suffer
Account deleted




Homer wrote:
Ruee wrote:
Pavlov wrote:
humans and animals are two completely different things

why ? sure they can be dumb as rocks but intelligence is not why we have empathy for other things/people. that would be fucked up. and believe me, they do feel emotions, at least some of them i can be sure
that's fucked

what ? i don't care about their intelligence. but i know that people put animals on lower level just because they can't talk or fight back. reality sucks
Homer
Streetmusician



Pavlov wrote:
kagura wrote:
Pavlov wrote:
if your arguement was to work we would have to live by the same laws as animals, that would mean that either we would be allowed to murder and eat eachother or animals would have to start shopping on walmart
i have no problem with animals shopping at walmart

yes of course we're different from other animals. but we both have same basics needs and emotions. no animal wants to die so it's not okay to kill them for fun.
making animals not live by their natural instincts would be animal abuse, and nobody is talking about killing them for fun
what do you mean?
Private
National Star



Pavlov wrote:
kagura wrote:
Pavlov wrote:
if your arguement was to work we would have to live by the same laws as animals, that would mean that either we would be allowed to murder and eat eachother or animals would have to start shopping on walmart
i have no problem with animals shopping at walmart

yes of course we're different from other animals. but we both have same basics needs and emotions. no animal wants to die so it's not okay to kill them for fun.
making animals not live by their natural instincts would be animal abuse, and nobody is talking about killing them for fun
so cats and dogs are abuse?
Post comment
Post Comment
To load new posts: activated
First | Previous | Page: | Next | Last