You have not yet responded to the forum.

Here you will find the last 3 forum topics
you have posted a comment on.
0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0
0%
+ add shout
Meister
R U =0)
To join the forums you need to be logged in.

Click here to register your own account for free and I will personally explain to you how you can start getting your own fans and, making popdollars.
> Close
Helper
12 of the 24 stars earned

Forum

General < General First | Previous | Page: | Next | Last
dissociaDID
Private
World Famous



Koolaid wrote:
after watching the video with all her alters it's so hard to wrap my head around it

it's a known occurrence that people can completely disassociate during traumatic events and completely not remember them / repress them in a way to protect your mental state.

but to have distinct personalities, each with their own name, identity, that are more or less fixed.
just the having of such a clear compartmentalisation in your head abt who is who, who remembers what and such is so ... scientifical / determined in a sense? like usually mental disorders are very wishy washy but aside from the personalities, all these people seem to be very clear in what they know/don't know
I honestly think that the tv show United States of Tara is more realistic than Cloe is. LIke on that show all her alters are different aspects of Tara, they're all still Tara but different aspects of her. Not like a completely different person who is a different race. I think that's more likely how things are with DID assuming that DID is real. 
Private
Popstar



Claire wrote:
Koolaid wrote:
after watching the video with all her alters it's so hard to wrap my head around it

it's a known occurrence that people can completely disassociate during traumatic events and completely not remember them / repress them in a way to protect your mental state.

but to have distinct personalities, each with their own name, identity, that are more or less fixed.
just the having of such a clear compartmentalisation in your head abt who is who, who remembers what and such is so ... scientifical / determined in a sense? like usually mental disorders are very wishy washy but aside from the personalities, all these people seem to be very clear in what they know/don't know
I honestly think that the tv show United States of Tara is more realistic than Cloe is. LIke on that show all her alters are different aspects of Tara, they're all still Tara but different aspects of her. Not like a completely different person who is a different race. I think that's more likely how things are with DID assuming that DID is real. 
No, thats osdd 1a, not DID
Private
World Famous



ouch wrote:
Claire wrote:
Koolaid wrote:
after watching the video with all her alters it's so hard to wrap my head around it

it's a known occurrence that people can completely disassociate during traumatic events and completely not remember them / repress them in a way to protect your mental state.

but to have distinct personalities, each with their own name, identity, that are more or less fixed.
just the having of such a clear compartmentalisation in your head abt who is who, who remembers what and such is so ... scientifical / determined in a sense? like usually mental disorders are very wishy washy but aside from the personalities, all these people seem to be very clear in what they know/don't know
I honestly think that the tv show United States of Tara is more realistic than Cloe is. LIke on that show all her alters are different aspects of Tara, they're all still Tara but different aspects of her. Not like a completely different person who is a different race. I think that's more likely how things are with DID assuming that DID is real. 
No, thats osdd 1a, not DID
then my opinion is that osdd 1a is probably more likely to be real than did is. 
Private
Popstar



Claire wrote:
ouch wrote:
Claire wrote:
I honestly think that the tv show United States of Tara is more realistic than Cloe is. LIke on that show all her alters are different aspects of Tara, they're all still Tara but different aspects of her. Not like a completely different person who is a different race. I think that's more likely how things are with DID assuming that DID is real. 
No, thats osdd 1a, not DID
then my opinion is that osdd 1a is probably more likely to be real than did is. 
Yes, not that dissociadid is a worse representation of did 
Private
World Famous



Persona wrote:
Claire wrote:
Persona wrote:
Since she paid, she went private. I don't know how things work under private psychiatry (because i'm poor lol). Under the NHS, they tend to diagnose you in the first meeting, yes. At least I was. But that's because you only see a psychiatrist every like, 4 months anyway (if you're lucky...). If they waited several meetings to diagnose you you'd never get a diagnosis.
this is why american's don't want public healthcare i can see my psych four times a month if i wanted to.
yeah, it's awful. You only ever see a psych if you're really really unwell (because the waiting lists would be even longer than they are now...). Otherwise you can see a nurse therapist once a fortnight maybe. But that's only for like 10 sessions, and then they discharge you.

I have to say, she's incredibly lucky to have the option to go private and no NHS psych would have ever diagnosed her with DID
it looks like there's only two places to get a did diagnosis in the uk 

cloe got hers at a place called pottergate centre
Private
Princess of Pop



Claire wrote:
ouch wrote:
Claire wrote:
I honestly think that the tv show United States of Tara is more realistic than Cloe is. LIke on that show all her alters are different aspects of Tara, they're all still Tara but different aspects of her. Not like a completely different person who is a different race. I think that's more likely how things are with DID assuming that DID is real. 
No, thats osdd 1a, not DID
then my opinion is that osdd 1a is probably more likely to be real than did is. 
I wish I could agree but I've seen my case and .. well.. yeah.
Private
World Famous



Claire wrote:
Persona wrote:
Claire wrote:
this is why american's don't want public healthcare i can see my psych four times a month if i wanted to.
yeah, it's awful. You only ever see a psych if you're really really unwell (because the waiting lists would be even longer than they are now...). Otherwise you can see a nurse therapist once a fortnight maybe. But that's only for like 10 sessions, and then they discharge you.

I have to say, she's incredibly lucky to have the option to go private and no NHS psych would have ever diagnosed her with DID
it looks like there's only two places to get a did diagnosis in the uk 

cloe got hers at a place called pottergate centre
she moved to norwich for university and this centre just happens to be in norwich
Private
Popstar



ouch wrote:
Koolaid wrote:
after watching the video with all her alters it's so hard to wrap my head around it

it's a known occurrence that people can completely disassociate during traumatic events and completely not remember them / repress them in a way to protect your mental state.

but to have distinct personalities, each with their own name, identity, that are more or less fixed.
just the having of such a clear compartmentalisation in your head abt who is who, who remembers what and such is so ... scientifical / determined in a sense? like usually mental disorders are very wishy washy but aside from the personalities, all these people seem to be very clear in what they know/don't know
Osdd 1a is practically did without fully formed personalities, so not strong enough identitys to classify as did, and osdd 1b is did without amnesia between the alters, that sounds like what ur talking abt but
thanks for telling me! it's super complicated to me because i have no background is psychology and this is all news to me
Private
World Famous



Abby wrote:
Claire wrote:
ouch wrote:
No, thats osdd 1a, not DID
then my opinion is that osdd 1a is probably more likely to be real than did is. 
I wish I could agree but I've seen my case and .. well.. yeah.
is this conversation difficult? i would assume reading this thread might be triggering. 
Persona
Streetmusician



Claire wrote:
Persona wrote:
Claire wrote:
this is why american's don't want public healthcare i can see my psych four times a month if i wanted to.
yeah, it's awful. You only ever see a psych if you're really really unwell (because the waiting lists would be even longer than they are now...). Otherwise you can see a nurse therapist once a fortnight maybe. But that's only for like 10 sessions, and then they discharge you.

I have to say, she's incredibly lucky to have the option to go private and no NHS psych would have ever diagnosed her with DID
it looks like there's only two places to get a did diagnosis in the uk 

cloe got hers at a place called pottergate centre
tbh it's incredibly dodgy to me that this centre is like 'give us money and you'll get the diagnose you want'. 
Private
World Famous



i just found this screenshot and i just want to say i think it's funny that i got webmd linked to me in this thread as a reliable medical source and here cloe is saying that its a bad source

Private
Popstar



it does say that DID is one of the most controversial disorders bc of how poorly researched it is.. i mean how can you research something like this and make sure your subjects are not faking it? is it similar to how people research things like schizophrenia and such? i do wonder
Private
World Famous



Koolaid wrote:
it does say that DID is one of the most controversial disorders bc of how poorly researched it is.. i mean how can you research something like this and make sure your subjects are not faking it? is it similar to how people research things like schizophrenia and such? i do wonder
brain scans would be the most useful i think but it would be difficult to even find enough subjects to test with
Private
Princess of Pop



Claire wrote:
Abby wrote:
Claire wrote:
then my opinion is that osdd 1a is probably more likely to be real than did is. 
I wish I could agree but I've seen my case and .. well.. yeah.
is this conversation difficult? i would assume reading this thread might be triggering. 
it was not hard at first and now it makes me feel kinda bad tbh
feels like I'm dissociating a bit
but my mentality is wack either way so I don't know at the moment if this is it but I think it is.
Private
Popstar



Koolaid wrote:
ouch wrote:
Koolaid wrote:
after watching the video with all her alters it's so hard to wrap my head around it

it's a known occurrence that people can completely disassociate during traumatic events and completely not remember them / repress them in a way to protect your mental state.

but to have distinct personalities, each with their own name, identity, that are more or less fixed.
just the having of such a clear compartmentalisation in your head abt who is who, who remembers what and such is so ... scientifical / determined in a sense? like usually mental disorders are very wishy washy but aside from the personalities, all these people seem to be very clear in what they know/don't know
Osdd 1a is practically did without fully formed personalities, so not strong enough identitys to classify as did, and osdd 1b is did without amnesia between the alters, that sounds like what ur talking abt but
thanks for telling me! it's super complicated to me because i have no background is psychology and this is all news to me
Here if u wanna know more
Post comment
Post Comment
To load new posts: activated
First | Previous | Page: | Next | Last