You have not yet responded to the forum.

Here you will find the last 3 forum topics
you have posted a comment on.
0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0
0%
+ add shout
Meister
R U =0)
To join the forums you need to be logged in.

Click here to register your own account for free and I will personally explain to you how you can start getting your own fans and, making popdollars.
> Close
Helper
17 of the 24 stars earned

Forum

General < General First | Previous | Page: | Next | Last
Heaven or hell
Private
Popstar



ouch wrote:
Rainstorm wrote:
Slu7 wrote:
How do you define evil? From your point of view
I'd say that people that have caused too much pain upon innocent people are defined as evil. I don't think you can hold someone captive against their will and do however you'd please with that person and not be considered evil. I don't find it necessary to dig up extreme examples of this but I'd say most have a pretty "standard imagery" of what evil is. Im sure you do as well

Every now and then you hear about people that have murdered and cut innocent people up and hid their bodies, I mean what's the excuse for that? Mental illness? I don't think so. I'd be nice to know these people got the treatment they deserve after life on earth and not just "I was forgiven so now I'm in heaven "-kinda thing
Csn I just say, it may very well be that mental illness is the cause 
Just stop
Private
Popstar



askr wrote:
Rainstorm wrote:
LitroTrope wrote:
No one can go to heaven because of their own actions. If it were up to me and the life I've lived, I'd definitely go to hell.

The gospel message is simple, God gave his only begotten son, to die and the cross and take all of the worlds sins. Therefore, anyone who believes in Him, can be saved. 
Going to heaven is not an achievement, it is the free gift of God, that you can choose to recieve. 

Think of it this way: if you break the law, you won't be let off the hook for good deeds like giving money to charity or helping an old lady cross the street. However, if someone were to pay the the fine/or the bail money for you, then you are free to go, legally and justly. 
Technically, you're right but I see it from another perspective I guess. For me it's not all about Jesus because I don't think it's right for somebody to cause however much harm they'd like and then turn to Jesus for forgiveness last minute. Maybe I'm wrong for thinking this way but I find it very hard to believe that anyone can be saved. I believe evil exist in this universe for a reason and if something is truly evil, there's no saving that.....  

Wow I come across as very anti-Christian right now and I apologize for that but this is what I truly think.......
It's not about the timing, it's whether you are genuine or not. I too think that some things are too evil to ever be forgiven. You can't just go murder a bunch of innocent people and then say sorry and expect everything to be fine. I'd want to watch that person burn. Therefore I'm glad it's not me judging. Or you, or any of us. If God is real, he would know the persons heart, and judge him based on that. 
I agree but how can somebody genuinely feel bad for what they've done if they've committed some very horrible and evil acts? I just don't see how that is possible
Aske
Prince of Pop



Rainstorm wrote:
askr wrote:
Rainstorm wrote:
Technically, you're right but I see it from another perspective I guess. For me it's not all about Jesus because I don't think it's right for somebody to cause however much harm they'd like and then turn to Jesus for forgiveness last minute. Maybe I'm wrong for thinking this way but I find it very hard to believe that anyone can be saved. I believe evil exist in this universe for a reason and if something is truly evil, there's no saving that.....  

Wow I come across as very anti-Christian right now and I apologize for that but this is what I truly think.......
It's not about the timing, it's whether you are genuine or not. I too think that some things are too evil to ever be forgiven. You can't just go murder a bunch of innocent people and then say sorry and expect everything to be fine. I'd want to watch that person burn. Therefore I'm glad it's not me judging. Or you, or any of us. If God is real, he would know the persons heart, and judge him based on that. 
I agree but how can somebody genuinely feel bad for what they've done if they've committed some very horrible and evil acts? I just don't see how that is possible

Do you never regret things? They may not have felt bad about it at the moment, but people change. Some people change a lot. There can be a lot of different reasons behind people doing evil things, we only see the actions, not what's behind them. Some people are ill, some are brainwashed, some are scared, whatever it might be, it's a good thing that you are not damned for eternity if you go down a wrong path and only realize later. 
Private
International Star



Like christian shit? That if you just believe in god and ask for forgiveness you go heaven no matter what?
nope not going
Private
Popstar



askr wrote:
Rainstorm wrote:
askr wrote:
It's not about the timing, it's whether you are genuine or not. I too think that some things are too evil to ever be forgiven. You can't just go murder a bunch of innocent people and then say sorry and expect everything to be fine. I'd want to watch that person burn. Therefore I'm glad it's not me judging. Or you, or any of us. If God is real, he would know the persons heart, and judge him based on that. 
I agree but how can somebody genuinely feel bad for what they've done if they've committed some very horrible and evil acts? I just don't see how that is possible

Do you never regret things? They may not have felt bad about it at the moment, but people change. Some people change a lot. There can be a lot of different reasons behind people doing evil things, we only see the actions, not what's behind them. Some people are ill, some are brainwashed, some are scared, whatever it might be, it's a good thing that you are not damned for eternity if you go down a wrong path and only realize later. 
I've seen far too many court documents and interrogations of the accused trying to bargain for the insanity plea. I don't think it's right that you can hide behind sort of shield instead of getting actual consequences for what you've done.

You said it yourself, "I too think that some things are too evil to ever be forgiven. You can't just go murder a bunch of innocent people and then say sorry and expect everything to be fine" and that's exactly what I'm trying to say here
Private
Popstar



Rainstorm wrote:
askr wrote:
Rainstorm wrote:
I agree but how can somebody genuinely feel bad for what they've done if they've committed some very horrible and evil acts? I just don't see how that is possible

Do you never regret things? They may not have felt bad about it at the moment, but people change. Some people change a lot. There can be a lot of different reasons behind people doing evil things, we only see the actions, not what's behind them. Some people are ill, some are brainwashed, some are scared, whatever it might be, it's a good thing that you are not damned for eternity if you go down a wrong path and only realize later. 
I've seen far too many court documents and interrogations of the accused trying to bargain for the insanity plea. I don't think it's right that you can hide behind sort of shield instead of getting actual consequences for what you've done.

You said it yourself, "I too think that some things are too evil to ever be forgiven. You can't just go murder a bunch of innocent people and then say sorry and expect everything to be fine" and that's exactly what I'm trying to say here
You do know you will get punished by law even tho you are deemed insane in court, right 
What if someone is psychotic for example, and kill someone, that is not reflective of them as a person, and when they go out of the psychosis they may very well be sorry for what they have done 
Private
Popstar



ouch wrote:
Rainstorm wrote:
askr wrote:

Do you never regret things? They may not have felt bad about it at the moment, but people change. Some people change a lot. There can be a lot of different reasons behind people doing evil things, we only see the actions, not what's behind them. Some people are ill, some are brainwashed, some are scared, whatever it might be, it's a good thing that you are not damned for eternity if you go down a wrong path and only realize later. 
I've seen far too many court documents and interrogations of the accused trying to bargain for the insanity plea. I don't think it's right that you can hide behind sort of shield instead of getting actual consequences for what you've done.

You said it yourself, "I too think that some things are too evil to ever be forgiven. You can't just go murder a bunch of innocent people and then say sorry and expect everything to be fine" and that's exactly what I'm trying to say here
You do know you will get punished by law even tho you are deemed insane in court, right 
What if someone is psychotic for example, and kill someone, that is not reflective of them as a person, and when they go out of the psychosis they may very well be sorry for what they have done 
Obviously, but they will be treated for their "mental illness" and will NOT receive the same punishment someone that is considered sane would've
Aske
Prince of Pop



Rainstorm wrote:
askr wrote:
Rainstorm wrote:
I agree but how can somebody genuinely feel bad for what they've done if they've committed some very horrible and evil acts? I just don't see how that is possible

Do you never regret things? They may not have felt bad about it at the moment, but people change. Some people change a lot. There can be a lot of different reasons behind people doing evil things, we only see the actions, not what's behind them. Some people are ill, some are brainwashed, some are scared, whatever it might be, it's a good thing that you are not damned for eternity if you go down a wrong path and only realize later. 
I've seen far too many court documents and interrogations of the accused trying to bargain for the insanity plea. I don't think it's right that you can hide behind sort of shield instead of getting actual consequences for what you've done.

You said it yourself, "I too think that some things are too evil to ever be forgiven. You can't just go murder a bunch of innocent people and then say sorry and expect everything to be fine" and that's exactly what I'm trying to say here

Heaven and hell isn't court tho. You can't plea insanity in front of God. He knows. He know your heart, you can't trick him. 
I said that yes, because when i see actions like that, i want revenge. Instinctively i guess, i'm not perfect. Wouldn't you agree that mercy and forgiveness is better than revenge and payback?
Private
Popstar



Rainstorm wrote:
ouch wrote:
Rainstorm wrote:
I've seen far too many court documents and interrogations of the accused trying to bargain for the insanity plea. I don't think it's right that you can hide behind sort of shield instead of getting actual consequences for what you've done.

You said it yourself, "I too think that some things are too evil to ever be forgiven. You can't just go murder a bunch of innocent people and then say sorry and expect everything to be fine" and that's exactly what I'm trying to say here
You do know you will get punished by law even tho you are deemed insane in court, right 
What if someone is psychotic for example, and kill someone, that is not reflective of them as a person, and when they go out of the psychosis they may very well be sorry for what they have done 
Obviously, but they will be treated for their "mental illness" and will NOT receive the same punishment someone that is considered sane would've
No because they can't be held responsible for their crime in the same way? They get treated for mental illness in a facility for criminally insane people (and people there are very mentally ill believe it or not) and they will often get longer sentences than if they were to get a regular sentence without being ill
Private
Popstar



ouch wrote:
Rainstorm wrote:
ouch wrote:
You do know you will get punished by law even tho you are deemed insane in court, right 
What if someone is psychotic for example, and kill someone, that is not reflective of them as a person, and when they go out of the psychosis they may very well be sorry for what they have done 
Obviously, but they will be treated for their "mental illness" and will NOT receive the same punishment someone that is considered sane would've
No because they can't be held responsible for their crime in the same way? They get treated for mental illness in a facility for criminally insane people (and people there are very mentally ill believe it or not) and they will often get longer sentences than if they were to get a regular sentence without being ill
Let me give you an example. It's like the infamous school-shooter kid that killed 17 people I believe. He's still alive and well after showing off his fine acting skills

There have been people that have gotten the death penalty for much less than that. Some for "only" 1 murder

Do you think that is fair?
LitroTrope
International Star



Rainstorm wrote:
LitroTrope wrote:
Rainstorm wrote:
Technically, you're right but I see it from another perspective I guess. For me it's not all about Jesus because I don't think it's right for somebody to cause however much harm they'd like and then turn to Jesus for forgiveness last minute. Maybe I'm wrong for thinking this way but I find it very hard to believe that anyone can be saved. I believe evil exist in this universe for a reason and if something is truly evil, there's no saving that.....  

Wow I come across as very anti-Christian right now and I apologize for that but this is what I truly think.......
I can definitely see where you are coming from! There is nothing to apologize for at all. I'm happy to hear you voice your true opinion! 

I don't think anyone can do whatever they want and then just say "oops, sorry", the last minute and that always fixes everything. There is a lot of nuances to this topic but from a biblical perspective it's God who knows your heart.

When Jesus died on the cross, there were two convicted criminals also being crucified with him. One of them asked him to remember him when he entered paradise. Jesus said "today you will be with me in paradise", which means it is possible to be forgiven, without having the time or chance to show with actions that you are repentant. However in the bible there are also instances where people are unable to repent. When the jews were in Egypt the Pharao had time to change his mind, but after a while it was to late and his heart was hardened. 

It is never smart to keep going against your consience until you don't feel bad about anything anymore. At a certain point you've goon to far. 

According to the bible evil exists because we have a free will with a choice to do what we want to. Breaking the law (that God created), creates suffering.

The way I see it, anyone can be saved, but that doesn't mean everyone will. People who have done horrible things can be forgiven, but not if there is no repentance. God knows our actions and our hearts. 
This is what I think as well! Maybe it's more about me not thinking evil people can be forgiven because they don't have it in their hearts to be forgiven... I just find it hard to believe that some people can do horrendous and awful things throughout their life and then genuinely feel sorry for it 

I think you put it in a VERY good way when you said "anyone can be saved, but that doesn't mean everyone will. People who have done horrible things can be forgiven, but not if there is no repentance. God knows our actions and our hearts" but still, I don't want some people to be forgiven..... I truly don't..... and maybe I'm wrong for thinking that way but it seems more fair that you get consequences for your actions whether you're remorseful or not when it's too late. It's not like you can go back in time and take away the pain from the people you've caused pain upon, you know

You obviously know what you're talking about so I appreciate you sharing your thoughts as well!! 
I again understand what you mean, and I agree with some of it. However, I do think some people who did really bad things, have and will be saved, and completely changed. Of course this doesn't mean actions don't have consequences. I think it shows how God is powerful and merciful. He has the power to change hearts.

Here I have some ecamples of what I mean:
1. The apostle Paul. Probably the man who has been the most important for Christianity (Other than Christ of course). Why? He was an enemy of Jesus and his followers. After the death of Jesus, believers testified to having seen him alive. Many followers still existed, even though they were in danger of being martyred. Paul hated these people and had them arrested and killed. One day on the road to Damaskus saw a Great Light and heard a voice saying "Saul, Saul, why do you persecute me?". Paul fell to the ground and asked "who are you lord?". He was told: "I am Jesus, whom you are persecuting". Then he was told to go to the city and he would be told what to do next. The people travelling with him helped him get to the city.

Theres a bit more to this story but, the end result was, he was healed and got his sight back. He found out that he had been persecuting believers of God. He thought he was getting rid of people who believed in a false version of God. His life was completely changed by God, and he spread the message of his experience and spread the gospel in Asia. He was an enemy turned believer. A strong case for the ressurection of Chist, since both believers and unbelievers testified to seeing him alive after the crucifixion.

I also believe there are many examples right now, one good one I think is David Wood. You can read his story here: https://www.premierchristianity.com/Past-Issues/2016/May-2016/David-Wood-From-Nihilism-To-New-Life
Or watch his video witnessing about his experience: 
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DakEcY7Z5GU&t=797s&user=UCy5H0uunC2qMk0iOF4SHKUw&ab_channel=Acts17Apologetics

He is a man with ASPD (sociopathy), and also suffered from delusions. He tried to kill his own father. He lived his life without the ability to feel bad about anything, he didn't have empathy. He went to prison and met a christian there. He ended up reading the bible (to prove his friend wrong). He began believing, and Jesus changed his heart. His father had survived and they both were able to be reconciled. (Must have been extremely tough for the father, I can't even imagine). Now he has a family and doesn't have violent urges anymore. 

Of course, an important thing when you become a christian is to make up for things that you have done, when you have the ability. Return stolen items or compensate with money etc. Tell the truth and ask for forgiveness. Do what you can to make up your wrongs. 

I think God can really create miracles that we would never believe. Things that are impossible to do on our own, are things that are easy for God. However, you have to be willing to let Him change you, because it is your own choice. 

Sorry for the long post I find this topic extremely interesting 
Private
Popstar



askr wrote:
Rainstorm wrote:
askr wrote:

Do you never regret things? They may not have felt bad about it at the moment, but people change. Some people change a lot. There can be a lot of different reasons behind people doing evil things, we only see the actions, not what's behind them. Some people are ill, some are brainwashed, some are scared, whatever it might be, it's a good thing that you are not damned for eternity if you go down a wrong path and only realize later. 
I've seen far too many court documents and interrogations of the accused trying to bargain for the insanity plea. I don't think it's right that you can hide behind sort of shield instead of getting actual consequences for what you've done.

You said it yourself, "I too think that some things are too evil to ever be forgiven. You can't just go murder a bunch of innocent people and then say sorry and expect everything to be fine" and that's exactly what I'm trying to say here

Heaven and hell isn't court tho. You can't plea insanity in front of God. He knows. He know your heart, you can't trick him. 
I said that yes, because when i see actions like that, i want revenge. Instinctively i guess, i'm not perfect. Wouldn't you agree that mercy and forgiveness is better than revenge and payback?
Absolutely not. Not all deserves mercy and forgiveness and those who don't deserve it should get, perhaps not revenge, but certainly be given fair consequences for what they've done
Private
Popstar



Rainstorm wrote:
ouch wrote:
Rainstorm wrote:
Obviously, but they will be treated for their "mental illness" and will NOT receive the same punishment someone that is considered sane would've
No because they can't be held responsible for their crime in the same way? They get treated for mental illness in a facility for criminally insane people (and people there are very mentally ill believe it or not) and they will often get longer sentences than if they were to get a regular sentence without being ill
Let me give you an example. It's like the infamous school-shooter kid that killed 17 people I believe. He's still alive and well after showing off his fine acting skills

There have been people that have gotten the death penalty for much less than that. Some for "only" 1 murder

Do you think that is fair?
Do you believe in mental illness
As I said, you can't treat them the same way, it is inhumane. In norway, prisons aren't based around punishment either, but rehabilitation (and guess what, there are less re-offenders). I don't think anyone should get the death penalty, and I don't believe you should get the same treatment if you are mentally ill or not, because you can't be held responsible in the same way
Private
Popstar



ouch wrote:
Rainstorm wrote:
ouch wrote:
No because they can't be held responsible for their crime in the same way? They get treated for mental illness in a facility for criminally insane people (and people there are very mentally ill believe it or not) and they will often get longer sentences than if they were to get a regular sentence without being ill
Let me give you an example. It's like the infamous school-shooter kid that killed 17 people I believe. He's still alive and well after showing off his fine acting skills

There have been people that have gotten the death penalty for much less than that. Some for "only" 1 murder

Do you think that is fair?
Do you believe in mental illness
As I said, you can't treat them the same way, it is inhumane. In norway, prisons aren't based around punishment either, but rehabilitation (and guess what, there are less re-offenders). I don't think anyone should get the death penalty, and I don't believe you should get the same treatment if you are mentally ill or not, because you can't be held responsible in the same way
You think THAT is inhumane but not the killing of 17 innocent people? Oh my

If you're screwed up in the head enough to kill innocent students that are just minding their own business, YES you deserve death. You were already given a chance in this lifetime and you completely ruined it for yourself and greatly hurt others along the way. Nah, I'm not about to defend schoolshooters here
Aske
Prince of Pop



Rainstorm wrote:
askr wrote:
Rainstorm wrote:
I've seen far too many court documents and interrogations of the accused trying to bargain for the insanity plea. I don't think it's right that you can hide behind sort of shield instead of getting actual consequences for what you've done.

You said it yourself, "I too think that some things are too evil to ever be forgiven. You can't just go murder a bunch of innocent people and then say sorry and expect everything to be fine" and that's exactly what I'm trying to say here

Heaven and hell isn't court tho. You can't plea insanity in front of God. He knows. He know your heart, you can't trick him. 
I said that yes, because when i see actions like that, i want revenge. Instinctively i guess, i'm not perfect. Wouldn't you agree that mercy and forgiveness is better than revenge and payback?
Absolutely not. Not all deserves mercy and forgiveness and those who don't deserve it should get, perhaps not revenge, but certainly be given fair consequences for what they've done

Well, than idk what to say really. That's medieval.

Facing the law they should get consequenses of course, but rehabilitation is much better than severe punishments. Not only is it more humane, but also much more effective. It's not satisfactory maybe, to know that a murderer is sleeping safely in a warm bed and gets decent food, but i don't think we want to go back to a society where we put them in a pillory or hang them on open street. 
Post comment
Post Comment
To load new posts: activated
First | Previous | Page: | Next | Last