Oniichan wrote:Snusmumrikken wrote:Oniichan wrote:
Saying this as a person living in Israel, with actually a lot of people that speak Yiddish, when they have Hebrew.. why
I understand the Orthodox people that live not in the jewland, but inside? Why?
Not to sound rude or anything but I think you might be a bit ignorant here?
Nono I'm not saying it's like bad or anything, I'm just curious,
But I assume that it's part of their identity and it's nice that they try not to let it die? But it don't understand how it was invented, and why use it more and refuse sometimes to speak Hebrew (the Yiddish speaking folk that livesnin Israel)
Sorry if it sounds bad haha
Natural languages are not invented unlike constructed languages, with either Esperanto or Klingon being the best examples on those. Natural languages, as long as they are "alive", have native speakers and new innovations. I assume Yiddish speakers have a relationship to Yiddish rather than Hebrew, expecting them to abandon an arguably large part of their identity just because they live in a country which have Hebrew as official language seems a bit cold to me. But it might be based on how we are taught a lot about the importance of native languages as Norway was HUGE on trying to eliminate all languages but Norwegian until embarrassingly recently, aka the 60s.