Snusmumrikken wrote:Oniichan wrote:Snusmumrikken wrote:
Idk I must say I think the opinion is a bit ignorant and uhh yes I don't really support your view here. It's a bit too conservative for my liking.
Guess I'm just saying I think it's weird oarts of them not willing to learn Hebrew ( not forgot their language for a new one, but add another that's part of their identity already)
I don't see why they should abandon their heritage, history is complicated. We have interesting cases up north were Finnish has evolved separately from the "mother language" Finnish, so Standard Finnish spoken in Finland, to two separate languages such as Kvensk in Norway and Meänkieli in Sweden. Finns tend to be very negative towards those languages as they perceive them as "lazy Finnish" or sloppy or whatever negative term you prefer, and that those speakers should learn "proper Finnish", but it's an ignorant view and blatantly ignores how languages evolve. 10,000 years ago, German and Norwegian were probably the same language, but you wouldn't today say that one of them are lazy versions of the other. As most people won't treat Afrikaans as lazy Dutch.
Learning new languages are challenging, as long as they get by adequately I don't see why we should force people into probably sounding dumb against their will. But language is complicated.
Not abandon, at least try to use that language that most related to their heritage and , of course that if they don't want to not force then, but after all as Jewish people well.. Hebrew is their native language, the problem with that language is just that ot was forgotten because In the past the got separated and lived in a lot of different countries and adapted to them.(for example, Yiddish being Hebrew mixed with German, also written in Hebrew)