You have not yet responded to the forum.

Here you will find the last 3 forum topics
you have posted a comment on.
0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0
0%
+ add shout
Meister
R U =0)
To join the forums you need to be logged in.

Click here to register your own account for free and I will personally explain to you how you can start getting your own fans and, making popdollars.
> Close
Helper
13 of the 24 stars earned

Forum

General < General First | Previous | Page: | Next | Last
dissociaDID
octocat
World Famous



Claire wrote:
Even if she really has DID like she says she does- the way she portrays it is a dangerous glorification of a debilitating disorder and her actions should be condemned. 
It's not though. She shows how people with DID can live someone normal and functioning lives, while also providing great factual/more serious videos. They're working against the stigma, trying to show that they're normal people
Private
World Famous



octocat wrote:
Claire wrote:
Even if she really has DID like she says she does- the way she portrays it is a dangerous glorification of a debilitating disorder and her actions should be condemned. 
It's not though. She shows how people with DID can live someone normal and functioning lives, while also providing great factual/more serious videos. They're working against the stigma, trying to show that they're normal people
But it is though. In order to be diagnosed with it (in the DSM that you mention) it HAS to be debilitating. It HAS to interfere with your ability to function in society in order to get the diagnosis.
Private
Princess of Pop



Claire wrote:
Even if she really has DID like she says she does- the way she portrays it is a dangerous glorification of a debilitating disorder and her actions should be condemned. 

I was really neutral this whole thread, but THIS..
as a person with DID this is the only thing I really disagree with, and as I said before,
I consider myself a confident person, but this? after such repeated trauma open up myself for everyone to see about this disorder??? I'd rather jump out the window.
octocat
World Famous



Claire wrote:
octocat wrote:
Honestly, have you no shame? How can you think it's okay so sit and speculate about another persons disorder. A highly complex and unique disorder. Just because you don't understand it doesn't give you any right to debate whether or not it's real. And pointing out a specific person as well, disgusting.

It doesn't matter if you "don't believe" it's a real disorder. It's recognized in the DSM. It's real.  
The DSM is made by people- people who don't always agree with each other. There will be a new DSM in a few years. We use the DSM 5 now. That means that psychologists have changed it five times already. They will change the DSM again. It's a socially constructed document.
Even if it's made by people, it's made by what we know NOW. Now, today, it's seen as a legitimate disorder. In 20, 30, 40 years maybe, when there's a new DSM, it won't be seen as a disorder. Or the criteria will change. But that doesn't make it less real in today's society.
Private
World Famous



octocat wrote:
Claire wrote:
octocat wrote:
Honestly, have you no shame? How can you think it's okay so sit and speculate about another persons disorder. A highly complex and unique disorder. Just because you don't understand it doesn't give you any right to debate whether or not it's real. And pointing out a specific person as well, disgusting.

It doesn't matter if you "don't believe" it's a real disorder. It's recognized in the DSM. It's real.  
The DSM is made by people- people who don't always agree with each other. There will be a new DSM in a few years. We use the DSM 5 now. That means that psychologists have changed it five times already. They will change the DSM again. It's a socially constructed document.
Even if it's made by people, it's made by what we know NOW. Now, today, it's seen as a legitimate disorder. In 20, 30, 40 years maybe, when there's a new DSM, it won't be seen as a disorder. Or the criteria will change. But that doesn't make it less real in today's society.

The DSM is a useful document for doctors to use to help treat people but it's not a bible and it's not infallable.
octocat
World Famous



Claire wrote:
octocat wrote:
Claire wrote:
Even if she really has DID like she says she does- the way she portrays it is a dangerous glorification of a debilitating disorder and her actions should be condemned. 
It's not though. She shows how people with DID can live someone normal and functioning lives, while also providing great factual/more serious videos. They're working against the stigma, trying to show that they're normal people
But it is though. In order to be diagnosed with it (in the DSM that you mention) it HAS to be debilitating. It HAS to interfere with your ability to function in society in order to get the diagnosis.
And she shows that it clearly does. But she's also worked with this disorder for years, so you learn to live with it. But that doesn't mean that you can have a normal day as well. Their normal is not the same as our normal, clearly. 
Private
World Famous



Claire wrote:
One of her alters is a horny Native American woman 

Claire wrote:
One of her alters is an anorexic 40 year old Japanese man. 

can we talk about how this is racist tho?
Private
National Star



ah, drama about someone elses mental disability....

honestly just STOP, aside from 1 person, none of y'all are in any position to judge this person.. or play doctor/therapist for that matter
octocat
World Famous



Avidan wrote:
ah, drama about someone elses mental disability....

honestly just STOP, aside from 1 person, none of y'all are in any position to judge this person.. or play doctor/therapist for that matter
^^^
Private
International Star



Avidan wrote:
ah, drama about someone elses mental disability....

honestly just STOP, aside from 1 person, none of y'all are in any position to judge this person.. or play doctor/therapist for that matter
lmao getting vee pee to stop judging stuff
i wish
Private
World Famous



Claire wrote:
Claire wrote:
One of her alters is a horny Native American woman 

Claire wrote:
One of her alters is an anorexic 40 year old Japanese man. 

can we talk about how this is racist tho?
Set aside the rest of the conversation.

Why are these alters different races? How? How does that happen and why? 
Private
International Star



Claire wrote:
Claire wrote:
Claire wrote:
One of her alters is a horny Native American woman 


can we talk about how this is racist tho?
Set aside the rest of the conversation.

Why are these alters different races? How? How does that happen and why? 
its not like u have any say in what they end up as?
Private
National Star



mikkelrev wrote:
Avidan wrote:
ah, drama about someone elses mental disability....

honestly just STOP, aside from 1 person, none of y'all are in any position to judge this person.. or play doctor/therapist for that matter
lmao getting vee pee to stop judging stuff
i wish
if i got 3 wishes from like a genie or something

one of those wishes would be to have these people not be smelly trash and whip up some good ol' drama just because they want to be right.. and if not, act like a toddler
Private
World Famous



mikkelrev wrote:
Claire wrote:
Claire wrote:


can we talk about how this is racist tho?
Set aside the rest of the conversation.

Why are these alters different races? How? How does that happen and why? 
its not like u have any say in what they end up as?
How does it happen though. Wouldn't they all be the race of the body? 
Private
Youtube Star



Avidan wrote:
mikkelrev wrote:
Avidan wrote:
ah, drama about someone elses mental disability....

honestly just STOP, aside from 1 person, none of y'all are in any position to judge this person.. or play doctor/therapist for that matter
lmao getting vee pee to stop judging stuff
i wish
if i got 3 wishes from like a genie or something

one of those wishes would be to have these people not be smelly trash and whip up some good ol' drama just because they want to be right.. and if not, act like a toddler
that would b an awful waste of a whole entire wish from a genie
Post comment
Post Comment
To load new posts: activated
First | Previous | Page: | Next | Last