You have not yet responded to the forum.

Here you will find the last 3 forum topics
you have posted a comment on.
0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0
0%
+ add shout
Private
send me wl :3
To join the forums you need to be logged in.

Click here to register your own account for free and I will personally explain to you how you can start getting your own fans and, making popdollars.
> Close
Helper
16 of the 24 stars earned

Forum

General < General Page: | Next | Last
Does the lack of action equal bad action in
Private
Popstar



Does the lack of action equal bad action in this scenario?

There's a woman drowning in a lake and you're the only person who witness it hence the only person who could help them

How would you categorize these three option? good, bad or neutral

a) you take the woman back to safety
b) you don't do anything and just watch as she drowns
c) you're the person who caused them to drown

Most would say a) is good c) is bad but what about b)?
Private
Popstar



And yeah, don't assume the woman drowning is a bad person that "should die" or something like that 
Private
Minister of Pop



If you're doing absolutely nothing because you just dont care then Id say thats bad yes
Private
Popstar



Its neutral, but it depends tho, like sometimes u cant do anything n then u just watch or go away from there 
Private
Popstar



ouch wrote:
Its neutral, but it depends tho, like sometimes u cant do anything n then u just watch or go away from there 
You could save them but chose not to
Account deleted




To be realistic, i am unfit. I would drown myself if I had to try save someone in a panic about to drown physically. If I could toss something out to the person, I'd do so, as long as it is relatively safe for myself as well. Obv. Would call the police or somth before I do anything to get ppl over there. 

A. Good? I mean you saved someones life. 
B. Bad. 
C.  Bad. That's murder if I am the reason they drowned. Not if I couldnt prevent them from drowning tho. Or if I caused the incident, like it would be unintenitional, indirect murder so i think thats pretty neutral.
Private
Popstar



Rainstorm wrote:
ouch wrote:
Its neutral, but it depends tho, like sometimes u cant do anything n then u just watch or go away from there 
You could save them but chose not to
Im saying I don't think anyone is a bad person or doing a bad action if they don't try to save someone when that could result in their own death or them being hurt. If you can't do anything without potentially dying or getting hurt, its not bad to prioritize one dead and one healthy over potentially two dead or hurt
Private
International Star



Rainstorm wrote:
ouch wrote:
Its neutral, but it depends tho, like sometimes u cant do anything n then u just watch or go away from there 
You could save them but chose not to
with all due respect, most people on this website will probably not have had the proper training for saving someone from drowning so they would most likely set themselves in danger and then two people die instead of one
Private
Popstar



ouch wrote:
Rainstorm wrote:
ouch wrote:
Its neutral, but it depends tho, like sometimes u cant do anything n then u just watch or go away from there 
You could save them but chose not to
Im saying I don't think anyone is a bad person or doing a bad action if they don't try to save someone when that could result in their own death or them being hurt. If you can't do anything without potentially dying or getting hurt, its not bad to prioritize one dead and one healthy over potentially two dead or hurt
No, I'm saying that you physically and mentally could save that woman but chose not to in option b). There's no risk for the person watching the woman drown to potentially die or get hurt.
Private
International Star



well i know how to help her since i've done the training, but honestly some people don't have that 

so for me, 

a) good
b) neutral/bad > basically depends on the person itself
c) bad

obviously you could call someone over or shout for help, but you don't really have that much time. and putting the pressure + blame on someone that physically or mentally can't do anything is wrong. 
Laboratory
World Famous



I mean I can't swim nd since finding help/ calling for help isn't one of the options I'd do b out of those,,,, guess the reasoning behind why ur just watching is what makes it either bad or good

a) you take the woman back to safety good
b) you don't do anything and just watch as she drowns depends
c) you're the person who caused them to drown bad
Private
Popstar



Rainstorm wrote:
ouch wrote:
Rainstorm wrote:
You could save them but chose not to
Im saying I don't think anyone is a bad person or doing a bad action if they don't try to save someone when that could result in their own death or them being hurt. If you can't do anything without potentially dying or getting hurt, its not bad to prioritize one dead and one healthy over potentially two dead or hurt
No, I'm saying that you physically and mentally could save that woman but chose not to in option b). There's no risk for the person watching the woman drown to potentially die or get hurt.
Then neutral/bad, but its not a realistic scenario 
Laboratory
World Famous



Rainstorm wrote:
ouch wrote:
Rainstorm wrote:
You could save them but chose not to
Im saying I don't think anyone is a bad person or doing a bad action if they don't try to save someone when that could result in their own death or them being hurt. If you can't do anything without potentially dying or getting hurt, its not bad to prioritize one dead and one healthy over potentially two dead or hurt
No, I'm saying that you physically and mentally could save that woman but chose not to in option b). There's no risk for the person watching the woman drown to potentially die or get hurt.

wtf kinda scenario is that
Private
World Famous



you never know how a person is gonna react and you cant base whether a person is good or bad on one scenario 
Private
International Star



Rainstorm wrote:
Does the lack of action equal bad action in this scenario?

There's a woman drowning in a lake and you're the only person who witness it hence the only person who could help them

How would you categorize these three option? good, bad or neutral

a) you take the woman back to safety
b) you don't do anything and just watch as she drowns
c) you're the person who caused them to drown

Most would say a) is good c) is bad but what about b)?
a) good
b) bad
c) bad

You can at least try something. Anything really. If you're just standing there watching them slowly drown, then that's really fucking wrong.
Private
Popstar



Anyways the point of this thread is, if you have the ability to help but chose not to (and there's no big risk factor for your own safety or anything like that) is it bad to not step in and help??

Like if you're on a walk down the neighborhood and you witness a young girl being kidnapped and you don't do anything about it? Does the lack of actions here make you a bad person? For example, not alerting anyone, not calling 911 etc.
Post comment
Post Comment
To load new posts: activated
Page: | Next | Last