You have not yet responded to the forum.

Here you will find the last 3 forum topics
you have posted a comment on.
0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0
0%
+ add shout
Meister
R U =0)
To join the forums you need to be logged in.

Click here to register your own account for free and I will personally explain to you how you can start getting your own fans and, making popdollars.
> Close
Helper
16 of the 24 stars earned

Forum

General < General Page: | Next | Last
Depiction of mental health in film/tv/novels
Persona
Streetmusician



talk about good and bad depictions of mental health that you've seen or read
Persona
Streetmusician



one really excellent depiction of depression imo is in the film Two Days, One Night. tw and all that, but u should check it out
Alam
World Famous



Can we not? I really don't want to.
Private
Popstar



Alam wrote:
Can we not? I really don't want to.
What
Account deleted




hmmm 
Private
Popstar



Anyways literally the only one I can think of is psycho (baits hotel series??) from 1960, I would say it can be a good depiction, esp in that time period, but also quite harmful
Private
International Star



Good Ones: 

- Even (bipolar disorder) in Skam

- Effy Stonem (psychosis,addiction and depression) in Skins

- Ian Gallagher (Bipolar disorder) Shameless (us) 

- Rue (addiciton and depression) Euphoria

- Noora (Anxiety) - Skam Norway

- Lauren Weil (PTSD) - Lauren Weil mini series


Bad ones:

- Girl Interrupted (main charachter cant remember her name) Borderline Personality disorder

- Silver Linings playbook (Bipolar disorder)

- 

Private
International Star



Alam wrote:
Can we not? I really don't want to.
then just click out of the topic?
Alam
World Famous



Utdatert wrote:
Alam wrote:
Can we not? I really don't want to.
then just click out of the topic?
'Twas a joke
December
World Famous



i'm not sure if girl, interruped it that good, but i think a lot of it is good even tho maybe it's a bit exaggerated sometimes. it's my favorite movie and it will always be anyways.
Private
Popstar



ouch wrote:
Anyways literally the only one I can think of is psycho (baits hotel series??) from 1960, I would say it can be a good depiction, esp in that time period, but also quite harmful
Oh yes since he is depicted to have did, he dresses as his mom and is describes as having the personality of both his mom and himself. His "mom" takes over his body when shes afraid of the son being taken away from her and murders the "threatening" women. So very harmful yes but how realistic it is as a whole I don't know
Private
Popstar



Oh and mr.robot, thats also did I believe, ive heard its quite realistic and good portrayal of did, but I dont have it so I can't reallly say 
December
World Famous



Utdatert wrote:
Good Ones: 

- Even (bipolar disorder) in Skam

- Effy Stonem (psychosis,addiction and depression) in Skins

- Ian Gallagher (Bipolar disorder) Shameless (us) 

- Rue (addiciton and depression) Euphoria

- Noora (Anxiety) - Skam Norway

- Lauren Weil (PTSD) - Lauren Weil mini series


Bad ones:

- Girl Interrupted (main charachter cant remember her name) Borderline Personality disorder

- Silver Linings playbook (Bipolar disorder)

- 
i think many of the other characters are pretty accurate tho, but i mean i'm not an expert i guess.
December
World Famous



idk if a beautiful mind is very accurate, i've heard that visual hallucinations like that are pretty rare.
Account deleted




Utdatert wrote:
Good Ones: 

- Even (bipolar disorder) in Skam

- Effy Stonem (psychosis,addiction and depression) in Skins

- Ian Gallagher (Bipolar disorder) Shameless (us) 

- Rue (addiciton and depression) Euphoria

- Noora (Anxiety) - Skam Norway

- Lauren Weil (PTSD) - Lauren Weil mini series


Bad ones:

- Girl Interrupted (main charachter cant remember her name) Borderline Personality disorder

- Silver Linings playbook (Bipolar disorder)

- 
Agreed on Girl interrupted and Euphoria. 
Private
International Star



tbh i think that the only shows who has managed to show mentall illness correctly is Skam Norway, Euphoria, Shameless and Skins


























Post comment
Post Comment
To load new posts: activated
Page: | Next | Last