You have not yet responded to the forum.

Here you will find the last 3 forum topics
you have posted a comment on.
0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0
0%
+ add shout
Meister
R U =0)
To join the forums you need to be logged in.

Click here to register your own account for free and I will personally explain to you how you can start getting your own fans and, making popdollars.
> Close
Helper
14 of the 24 stars earned

Forum

General < General Page: | Next | Last
transtrending
murdurur
National Star



i'm watching a really interesting docu about it right now and i have so many questions lol

if you believe it's real, what do you think causes it?
and what do you think of it in general? like is it a real thing and do you think it's okay to talk about it and ask questions?

do you have any personal experience?
murdurur
National Star



here's the documentary btw
Alam
World Famous



God, can we not?
murdurur
National Star



Alam wrote:
God, can we not?

i mean feel free to ignore this thread but i think it's an interesting topic
Midaas
World Famous



I've watched that documentary before
and I think that that phenomenon is really serious and it definitely should be studied so fucking much so we can help those ppl
murdurur
National Star



McMoney wrote:
I've watched that documentary before
and I think that that phenomenon is really serious and it definitely should be studied so fucking much so we can help those ppl

yeah i definitely agree with this
i think there can be many other reasons for feeling dysphoric about your gender than just the one reason of being transgender.

and i feel really bad about the people who decide to detransition and have to live with the changes hormones did to their bodies for the rest of their lives.
i think it's really important that their experiences are heard and talked about as well, and not just being silenced for being ''transphobic''.
Midaas
World Famous



murdurur wrote:
McMoney wrote:
I've watched that documentary before
and I think that that phenomenon is really serious and it definitely should be studied so fucking much so we can help those ppl

yeah i definitely agree with this
i think there can be many other reasons for feeling dysphoric about your gender than just the one reason of being transgender.

and i feel really bad about the people who decide to detransition and have to live with the changes hormones did to their bodies for the rest of their lives.
i think it's really important that their experiences are heard and talked about as well, and not just being silenced for being ''transphobic''.
this
Private
National Star



i've only ever seen people use the term 'transtrending' as an excuse to harass younger trans people. additionally, i can't find anything about the people that actually made the documentary, and it looks like they've only ever interviewed the doctors, and looked into a study of only two patients- it doesn't help that the video itself was uploaded by a christian homo/transphobe who is convinced that all trans people are trying to convert children so that they can take them away from god (???) and is reuploading the documentaries to sell his books.

for hormones, they only affect people permanently if they've taken them for several years, and the only permanent things are like (in cases of mtf) hair loss, low sperm count, and breast development, or (in cases of ftm) voice changes and hair loss.

for children, until they hit puberty, have had two therapists sign off on their dysphoria, and have a doctor approve them for transitioning, they will only ever receive puberty blockers- even then, kids have to deal with therapists not wanting to give them treatment on 'religious basis' (a family friend of ours is only starting to transition at 16, even though he's known since he was 8-9, because doctors kept denying him service for even things like standard checkups because he's trans). keep in mind that many cis kids also take puberty blockers for other various things such as height issues unrelated to dwarfism and early onset puberty (had i consulted a doctor, i most likely would have taken them myself, as i started periods and developing breasts at only 10).

i highly encourage you to talk to actual transgender people instead of harvesting your information online, especially if it's information that's readily shared by both religous groups and TERFs (i recognized the documentary since it's also being shared rapidly around TERF groups)

*edit- added citations for various things
murdurur
National Star



Specter wrote:
i've only ever seen people use the term 'transtrending' as an excuse to harass younger trans people. additionally, i can't find anything about the people that actually made the documentary, and it looks like they've only ever interviewed the doctors, and looked into a study of only two patients- it doesn't help that the video itself was uploaded by a christian homo/transphobe who is convinced that all trans people are trying to convert children so that they can take them away from god (???) and is reuploading the documentaries to sell his books.

for hormones, they only affect people permanently if they've taken them for several years, and the only permanent things are like (in cases of mtf) hair loss and breast development, or (in cases of ftm) voice changes and hair loss.

for children, until they hit puberty, have had two therapists sign off on their dysphoria, and have a doctor approve them for transitioning, they will only ever receive hormone blockers- even then, kids have to deal with therapists not wanting to give them treatment on 'religious basis' (a family friend of ours is only starting to transition at 16, even though he's known since he was 8-9, because doctors kept denying him service for even things like standard checkups because he's trans).

i highly encourage you to talk to actual transgender people instead of harvesting your information online, especially if it's information that's readily shared by both religous groups and TERFs (i recognized the documentary since it's also being shared rapidly around TERF groups)

i think it's irrelevant who uploaded the video. a swedish documentary is obviously going to be niche and hard to find so you just have to do with whatever source you can use.

i agree that transtrending is a controversial term though, but idk what else to call it. i think there is a trend happening, but of course i'm not saying any specific person or that everyone who wants to transition is wrong or that transgender people don't exist.

several doctors from multiple countries are interviewed in this documentary and they are also showing studies from sweden, norway and the uk.

this documentary also talks about how no one knows what the long term effects of hormone blockers are, and that hormones have a negative health effects as well, but i think that's kind of common knowledge.

i have had close transgender friends and i'm not judging trans people. i also don't hang out with terfs (i guess? it's not something i ever talk about so i guess some might consider themselves terfs without me knowing about it but i wouldn't really care if they did).

i think this is an actual, real issue that it's important to talk about and recognise that it doesn't make transgender people any less real. going on hormone treatment for someone who isn't actually trans is obviously going to be very damaging, emotionally, socially and physically and i think it's really disturbing and wrong that people are potentially being shamed for detransitioning or talking about the issue.
Private
Popstar



I think its real but not as big as it seems like, same as ppl saying they are bi/gay when they r not etc 
murdurur
National Star



they also talked to transgender people who aren't detransitioning and living satisfying, normal lives in the documentary as well as doctors who are exclusively positive about gender affirming treatment, so it really isn't just one angle being presented here.

and i think it's really important to keep in mind that the fact that some people receiving the wrong treatment doesn't make transgender people any less real.
Multatuli
International Star



Specter wrote:
i've only ever seen people use the term 'transtrending' as an excuse to harass younger trans people. additionally, i can't find anything about the people that actually made the documentary, and it looks like they've only ever interviewed the doctors, and looked into a study of only two patients- it doesn't help that the video itself was uploaded by a christian homo/transphobe who is convinced that all trans people are trying to convert children so that they can take them away from god (???) and is reuploading the documentaries to sell his books.

for hormones, they only affect people permanently if they've taken them for several years, and the only permanent things are like (in cases of mtf) hair loss, low sperm count, and breast development, or (in cases of ftm) voice changes and hair loss.

for children, until they hit puberty, have had two therapists sign off on their dysphoria, and have a doctor approve them for transitioning, they will only ever receive puberty blockers- even then, kids have to deal with therapists not wanting to give them treatment on 'religious basis' (a family friend of ours is only starting to transition at 16, even though he's known since he was 8-9, because doctors kept denying him service for even things like standard checkups because he's trans). keep in mind that many cis kids also take puberty blockers for other various things such as height issues unrelated to dwarfism and early onset puberty (had i consulted a doctor, i most likely would have taken them myself, as i started periods and developing breasts at only 10).

i highly encourage you to talk to actual transgender people instead of harvesting your information online, especially if it's information that's readily shared by both religous groups and TERFs (i recognized the documentary since it's also being shared rapidly around TERF groups)

*edit- added citations for various things
it's not like this concept doesn't exist though
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n0pVuZ0CT7Q&t=798s
obiously it is only one example but i feel like youre too quickly to dismiss the docu as a whole
Private
Youtube Star



Isn't transtrender just a person identifying as trans when they know they are not for some sort of gain, not the same as transitioning and detransitioning
Private
National Star



Skin wrote:
Isn't transtrender just a person identifying as trans when they know they are not for some sort of gain, not the same as transitioning and detransitioning
nah, it's a way of saying "i think you're faking being trans" that makes you look like less of a shitlord
murdurur
National Star



Skin wrote:
Isn't transtrender just a person identifying as trans when they know they are not for some sort of gain, not the same as transitioning and detransitioning

i think it also includes the people who start thinking they're trans because it's a big and very visible thing in their social circles too. Pretty much anyone who is influenced by a group of people or friends to think they're trans really.
Multatuli
International Star



Specter wrote:

i highly encourage you to talk to actual transgender people instead of harvesting your information online, especially if it's information that's readily shared by both religous groups and TERFs (i recognized the documentary since it's also being shared rapidly around TERF groups)

*edit- added citations for various things

Around 20 min there are also a few trans ppl talking btw
Post comment
Post Comment
To load new posts: activated
Page: | Next | Last