You have not yet responded to the forum.

Here you will find the last 3 forum topics
you have posted a comment on.
0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0
0%
+ add shout
Meister
R U =0)
To join the forums you need to be logged in.

Click here to register your own account for free and I will personally explain to you how you can start getting your own fans and, making popdollars.
> Close
Helper
17 of the 24 stars earned

Forum

General < General First | Previous | Page: | Next | Last
Depiction of mental health in film/tv/novels
Private
Popstar



And uhh all the bright places depicting bipolar, it was ok I guess, not damaging
Lornas127
International Star



I have always loved the analogy  that peoples lives are like plates.

Some can be ceramic but others are paper:
something that could not be see as do-able on one persons plate could be damaging for another person.

So treat people like an unknown plate, you don't know what their mental health material is. 
Private
International Star



Spoiler alert for fight club

Bad: split personality (DID?)  in fight club (film) because you can’t get rid of the disorder by shooting yourself in your cheek 
but then again the main character was also able to discuss with his other personality so idk what disorder you have to have to be able to do that
the book however is way more realistic compared to the movie
Private
International Star



acidreflux wrote:
December wrote:
Utdatert wrote:
Good Ones: 

- Even (bipolar disorder) in Skam

- Effy Stonem (psychosis,addiction and depression) in Skins

- Ian Gallagher (Bipolar disorder) Shameless (us) 

- Rue (addiciton and depression) Euphoria

- Noora (Anxiety) - Skam Norway

- Lauren Weil (PTSD) - Lauren Weil mini series


Bad ones:

- Girl Interrupted (main charachter cant remember her name) Borderline Personality disorder

- Silver Linings playbook (Bipolar disorder)

- 
i think many of the other characters are pretty accurate tho, but i mean i'm not an expert i guess.
after reading susanna kaysen's book, it's pretty accurate, but also a dramatisation, that proves the picture of how mental illness at the time period. the book was never intended to be a memoir or a biography, but rather an anthropologist view of mental illness (as said by susanna herself). 
honestly i feel like someone w bpd and other diagnosis', that it fits pretty well, all considering it has been altered to better be portrayed to the masses in cinema.
it does not fit tbh at all.. In fact, it fits more on Lisa than Susanna
Private
International Star



InAllRetrospect wrote:
Utdatert wrote:
Good Ones: 

- Even (bipolar disorder) in Skam

- Effy Stonem (psychosis,addiction and depression) in Skins

- Ian Gallagher (Bipolar disorder) Shameless (us) 

- Rue (addiciton and depression) Euphoria

- Noora (Anxiety) - Skam Norway

- Lauren Weil (PTSD) - Lauren Weil mini series


Bad ones:

- Girl Interrupted (main charachter cant remember her name) Borderline Personality disorder

- Silver Linings playbook (Bipolar disorder)

- 

I really agree with the skins and shameless examples

Another bad one is the multiple personality disorder/DID from the movie Split, that one was reeeeeally bad. 
100% agree
Private
International Star



Delusion1111111 wrote:
Utdatert wrote:
Good Ones: 

- Even (bipolar disorder) in Skam

- Effy Stonem (psychosis,addiction and depression) in Skins

- Ian Gallagher (Bipolar disorder) Shameless (us) 

- Rue (addiciton and depression) Euphoria

- Noora (Anxiety) - Skam Norway

- Lauren Weil (PTSD) - Lauren Weil mini series


Bad ones:

- Girl Interrupted (main charachter cant remember her name) Borderline Personality disorder

- Silver Linings playbook (Bipolar disorder)

- 

really wouldnt consider effy a good depiction
the depression and sleeping all day is accurate af , atleast to me it was like that
December
World Famous



Utdatert wrote:
acidreflux wrote:
December wrote:
i think many of the other characters are pretty accurate tho, but i mean i'm not an expert i guess.
after reading susanna kaysen's book, it's pretty accurate, but also a dramatisation, that proves the picture of how mental illness at the time period. the book was never intended to be a memoir or a biography, but rather an anthropologist view of mental illness (as said by susanna herself). 
honestly i feel like someone w bpd and other diagnosis', that it fits pretty well, all considering it has been altered to better be portrayed to the masses in cinema.
it does not fit tbh at all.. In fact, it fits more on Lisa than Susanna
i think lisa has more than just sociopathy, wouldn't surprise me if she had bpd too and 5 other diagnosis...
Private
Popstar



Raquelle wrote:
Spoiler alert for fight club

Bad: split personality (DID?)  in fight club (film) because you can’t get rid of the disorder by shooting yourself in your cheek 
but then again the main character was also able to discuss with his other personality so idk what disorder you have to have to be able to do that
the book however is way more realistic compared to the movie
Ppl with did can sometimes discuss with other people from their system inside their head so its not that weird, they can also have an inner space where the ppl live and is when they are not out, but shooting urself in the cheek to get rid of it however
Private
International Star



ouch wrote:
Raquelle wrote:
Spoiler alert for fight club

Bad: split personality (DID?)  in fight club (film) because you can’t get rid of the disorder by shooting yourself in your cheek 
but then again the main character was also able to discuss with his other personality so idk what disorder you have to have to be able to do that
the book however is way more realistic compared to the movie
Ppl with did can sometimes discuss with other people from their system inside their head so its not that weird, they can also have an inner space where the ppl live and is when they are not out, but shooting urself in the cheek to get rid of it however
Ooo i didn’t know that thanks!
so it’s at least little better than i thought that’s nice
December
World Famous



ouch wrote:
Raquelle wrote:
Spoiler alert for fight club

Bad: split personality (DID?)  in fight club (film) because you can’t get rid of the disorder by shooting yourself in your cheek 
but then again the main character was also able to discuss with his other personality so idk what disorder you have to have to be able to do that
the book however is way more realistic compared to the movie
Ppl with did can sometimes discuss with other people from their system inside their head so its not that weird, they can also have an inner space where the ppl live and is when they are not out, but shooting urself in the cheek to get rid of it however
i knew this because of dissociaDID on youtube, i love her and the system
Private
Popstar



December wrote:
ouch wrote:
Raquelle wrote:
Spoiler alert for fight club

Bad: split personality (DID?)  in fight club (film) because you can’t get rid of the disorder by shooting yourself in your cheek 
but then again the main character was also able to discuss with his other personality so idk what disorder you have to have to be able to do that
the book however is way more realistic compared to the movie
Ppl with did can sometimes discuss with other people from their system inside their head so its not that weird, they can also have an inner space where the ppl live and is when they are not out, but shooting urself in the cheek to get rid of it however
i knew this because of dissociaDID on youtube, i love her and the system
Have u seen all the drama with team pinata and dissociadid lately, big oof 
Private
International Star



Psychopathy / Sociopathy is actually very well portrayed in the movie Gone girl I think
Account deleted




"perfect blue" was excellent w thoughts of paranoia, trauma and depression. fuck i love that movie.
"helter skelter" is great too, i already adored the manga and then seeing the movie (although a let down), solidified the love i've for completely unhinged women.
"sleeping beauty" is a sneaker - it takes time before u realise it.
"martha marcy may marlene" fucked me up. yep, trauma and cult mentality are damaging af.
"the tracy fragments" u kno.
"mysterious skin" if u seen it, u know.
"speak" yep.
"the cell" but that's just me loving metaphors and abstract imagery.
"my own private idaho"
("altered states" only because it's a fucking acid trip";)
"suspiria"

i hate "shutter island" because yeah, trauma and denial can do that to you, but ugh, it's just so annoying to see in horror movies... especially when it's abt men. 
"hide and seek" fucking blows, i hate that movie so much. 
gotta admit, i fucking loved silent hill (i know vague hints, but still).
Persona
Streetmusician



ouch wrote:
December wrote:
ouch wrote:
Ppl with did can sometimes discuss with other people from their system inside their head so its not that weird, they can also have an inner space where the ppl live and is when they are not out, but shooting urself in the cheek to get rid of it however
i knew this because of dissociaDID on youtube, i love her and the system
Have u seen all the drama with team pinata and dissociadid lately, big oof 
yes D:
Account deleted




good: crazy ex girlfriend, star trek voyager, b99, probably more, but i can't think of any rn


bad : every tv show that makes the bad guy mentally ill for no reason
Post comment
Post Comment
To load new posts: activated
First | Previous | Page: | Next | Last