You have not yet responded to the forum.

Here you will find the last 3 forum topics
you have posted a comment on.
0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0
0%
+ add shout
Meister
R U =0)
To join the forums you need to be logged in.

Click here to register your own account for free and I will personally explain to you how you can start getting your own fans and, making popdollars.
> Close
Helper
18 of the 24 stars earned

Forum

General < General First | Previous | Page: | Next | Last
Depiction of mental health in film/tv/novels
December
World Famous



Utdatert wrote:
ouch wrote:
Utdatert wrote:
another bad one  (in my opinion) is anorexia potrayed in Red Band Society because it feels glamorizing
Every anorexia movie I know of is glamorizing but idk how ur supposed to do it without making it glamorized
skam (vilde and noora) did it well tho
omg yes i forgot about vilde! that was so good
Private
Youtube Star



i think broadchurch had a very good portrayal of grief. i know that's not like a disorder but it's kind of in the mental health realm anyway i feel like
December
World Famous



i think the end of the fucking world did it pretty realistic but at the same time not...
Private
Popstar



Utdatert wrote:
ouch wrote:
Utdatert wrote:
another bad one  (in my opinion) is anorexia potrayed in Red Band Society because it feels glamorizing
Every anorexia movie I know of is glamorizing but idk how ur supposed to do it without making it glamorized
skam (vilde and noora) did it well tho
Yes but a movie with just that little obvious behaviour would just be a movie with no theme at all
You wouldn't know they had eating disorder stuff if u weren't that "aware" I guess. Hidden is more accurate portrayal but it has to be dramatized when its the main theme and not just sub-plot 
Account deleted




Hate the social anxiety depiction in Finding Audrey lmao
Account deleted




ouch wrote:
Utdatert wrote:
ouch wrote:
Every anorexia movie I know of is glamorizing but idk how ur supposed to do it without making it glamorized
skam (vilde and noora) did it well tho
Yes but a movie with just that little obvious behaviour would just be a movie with no theme at all
You wouldn't know they had eating disorder stuff if u weren't that "aware" I guess. Hidden is more accurate portrayal but it has to be dramatized when its the main theme and not just sub-plot 
what is your opinion on to the bone
Private
Popstar



Ecentrah wrote:
ouch wrote:
Utdatert wrote:
skam (vilde and noora) did it well tho
Yes but a movie with just that little obvious behaviour would just be a movie with no theme at all
You wouldn't know they had eating disorder stuff if u weren't that "aware" I guess. Hidden is more accurate portrayal but it has to be dramatized when its the main theme and not just sub-plot 
what is your opinion on to the bone
Some good parts and some bad, ok-good portrayal ish, but still glorification but as I said it will always be like that
A movie with just "oh no u at my fish cake" or smth wouldn't really work imo, hence how I don't see how a movie (that ppl would actually watch) can be made without glorification because of the physical aspect of the illness, which is more "there" than other mental illnesses 
Private
International Star



autism is also very well portrayed in Atypical 


December
World Famous



Utdatert wrote:
autism is also very well portrayed in Atypical 
yes!!! i love that show so much
Private
International Star



December wrote:
Utdatert wrote:
autism is also very well portrayed in Atypical 
yes!!! i love that show so much
me too!
Private
World Famous



ouch wrote:
Ecentrah wrote:
ouch wrote:
Yes but a movie with just that little obvious behaviour would just be a movie with no theme at all
You wouldn't know they had eating disorder stuff if u weren't that "aware" I guess. Hidden is more accurate portrayal but it has to be dramatized when its the main theme and not just sub-plot 
what is your opinion on to the bone
Some good parts and some bad, ok-good portrayal ish, but still glorification but as I said it will always be like that
A movie with just "oh no u at my fish cake" or smth wouldn't really work imo, hence how I don't see how a movie (that ppl would actually watch) can be made without glorification because of the physical aspect of the illness, which is more "there" than other mental illnesses 
I think it's also more about creating awareness, than glorifying it.
Private
Popstar



Ella wrote:
ouch wrote:
Ecentrah wrote:
what is your opinion on to the bone
Some good parts and some bad, ok-good portrayal ish, but still glorification but as I said it will always be like that
A movie with just "oh no u at my fish cake" or smth wouldn't really work imo, hence how I don't see how a movie (that ppl would actually watch) can be made without glorification because of the physical aspect of the illness, which is more "there" than other mental illnesses 
I think it's also more about creating awareness, than glorifying it.
Yeah. My point is just its harder to portray an eating disorder in a non glorifying way than other mental illnesses, because of the physical aspect. Like that it works more as a sub-plot than the actual plot in a movie, cus its either gonna be over the top or boring 
Private
International Star



tbh I dont think Cassie in Skins is glamorized  as anorexic at all, but it might be becuse they dont focus only on her illness but more on her whole persona
Private
World Famous



ouch wrote:
Ella wrote:
ouch wrote:
Some good parts and some bad, ok-good portrayal ish, but still glorification but as I said it will always be like that
A movie with just "oh no u at my fish cake" or smth wouldn't really work imo, hence how I don't see how a movie (that ppl would actually watch) can be made without glorification because of the physical aspect of the illness, which is more "there" than other mental illnesses 
I think it's also more about creating awareness, than glorifying it.
Yeah. My point is just its harder to portray an eating disorder in a non glorifying way than other mental illnesses, because of the physical aspect. Like that it works more as a sub-plot than the actual plot in a movie, cus its either gonna be over the top or boring 
U are not wrong 
December
World Famous



Utdatert wrote:
tbh I dont think Cassie in Skins is glamorized  as anorexic at all, but it might be becuse they dont focus only on her illness but more on her whole persona
yeah i really agree. i think the depiction is pretty good actually, but i think they kinda glamorize her behaviour as charming and quirky...but i still think they did a good job
Post comment
Post Comment
To load new posts: activated
First | Previous | Page: | Next | Last