wug wrote:
Everything can in theory be problematic, and it's wrong to exclusively single out Islam as the problematic thing constantly because of Islamists. Sure, other groups get attacked and ridiculed as well, but I've not seen a group be as singled out in Norway and most of Europe as people who have ties to Islam in some way. They're frequently urged to collectively condemn terrorist attacks, only because those who conducted them "believe in Islam". In my opinion, it is an issue.
Alam wrote:
Radicalisation is relative, yeh? Say, in some orthodox/ultra orthodox Jewish communities, the idea of conversion therapy is completely sensical, while in any reform, conservative or secular Jewish communities the concept is absolutely radical. So when the starting point for Muslim people from Islamic countries is already radical from a progressive/"western" perspective, we have a problem. It's not a coincidence that many Islamic countries are going through war, civil strife and mass migration, because the ideals of Islam as they are at the moment are socially unsustainable, especially when faced with other parts of the world.
As to your point that sin is a Christian concept, that's just not true. Original sin is, yes, but sin as in "you did something God doesn't like, you shall be punished for it" is present in the main three Abrahamic religions at least (I honestly don't know much about other Abrahamic religions or otherwise so yeah), and it is a big part of Islam specifically. Regardless, I don't know why you brought up the religious aspect of it all, as in, what "the faith" (Islam is far from a monolith) encourages, because the bottom line is that many Islamic cultures encourage beliefs and actions that are harmful to people inside and outside of the religion, with what happened yesterday as an extreme result of that, so it doesn't really matter what scripture or religious scholars have to say.
Regardless of all that, I think I understand what your point is, which is that stating all of this (read: the obvious) is useless, or in fact, harmful to the vast majority of Muslims just living their lives and believing what they believe in the comfort of their own homes. I agree, I don't think there's really a point to saying "hey uh Islam is kinda problematic" without pointing to a solution, it's just a further dividing conversation, there's no point to it. Yeh.
Thank you for correcting me, I mixed up some religious concepts. And yes, it seems like you understood what my point is. I'm not defending their beliefs, I'm just saying that it's unfair, wrong and harmful to drag everyone for the actions of some (and in Europe, very few).Klasifikovany wrote:
Okay so Sobbing is incredibly inarticulate, no offence, and their point is uhhh misguided to say the least. But to equate modern Islam to modern Christianity is inaccurate and unfair. Modern Christianity, or at least most popular denominations of it, have evolved differently to Islam and to assume that they are equally incompatible with progressive/"western" ideals is just not true, they aren't. Sobbing wrote:
it is common for muslims because they believe in islam to be against lbqt
it is not common to be right wing for every white person
that is the difference
muslim people as a whole are not to be blamed for terrorist attacks, that is wrong
what is looked down on are their values or beliefs which are the reasons for SOME of the committed terrorist attacks
Radicalisation occurs in all groups regardless of the intention behind the "source material" that they use to justify their actions. It is fundamentally unfair to blame the religion for the action of radicalised members, we don't do it for any other religion and should therefore refrain from doing it with Islam. No religion would support murder of people regardless of whether they lead their life in "sin" (which is a Christian concept anyway), because other points should always cancel out that. Ultimately, in religion, god or the divinity of the religion or some other related concept is the final judge; the followers of the religion are never supposed to take this role. it is common for muslims because they believe in islam to be against lbqt
it is not common to be right wing for every white person
that is the difference
muslim people as a whole are not to be blamed for terrorist attacks, that is wrong
what is looked down on are their values or beliefs which are the reasons for SOME of the committed terrorist attacks
Radicalisation is relative, yeh? Say, in some orthodox/ultra orthodox Jewish communities, the idea of conversion therapy is completely sensical, while in any reform, conservative or secular Jewish communities the concept is absolutely radical. So when the starting point for Muslim people from Islamic countries is already radical from a progressive/"western" perspective, we have a problem. It's not a coincidence that many Islamic countries are going through war, civil strife and mass migration, because the ideals of Islam as they are at the moment are socially unsustainable, especially when faced with other parts of the world.
As to your point that sin is a Christian concept, that's just not true. Original sin is, yes, but sin as in "you did something God doesn't like, you shall be punished for it" is present in the main three Abrahamic religions at least (I honestly don't know much about other Abrahamic religions or otherwise so yeah), and it is a big part of Islam specifically. Regardless, I don't know why you brought up the religious aspect of it all, as in, what "the faith" (Islam is far from a monolith) encourages, because the bottom line is that many Islamic cultures encourage beliefs and actions that are harmful to people inside and outside of the religion, with what happened yesterday as an extreme result of that, so it doesn't really matter what scripture or religious scholars have to say.
Regardless of all that, I think I understand what your point is, which is that stating all of this (read: the obvious) is useless, or in fact, harmful to the vast majority of Muslims just living their lives and believing what they believe in the comfort of their own homes. I agree, I don't think there's really a point to saying "hey uh Islam is kinda problematic" without pointing to a solution, it's just a further dividing conversation, there's no point to it. Yeh.
Everything can in theory be problematic, and it's wrong to exclusively single out Islam as the problematic thing constantly because of Islamists. Sure, other groups get attacked and ridiculed as well, but I've not seen a group be as singled out in Norway and most of Europe as people who have ties to Islam in some way. They're frequently urged to collectively condemn terrorist attacks, only because those who conducted them "believe in Islam". In my opinion, it is an issue.



0
0
0
0
To join the forums you need to be logged in.


19