You have not yet responded to the forum.

Here you will find the last 3 forum topics
you have posted a comment on.
0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0
0%
+ add shout
Meister
R U =0)
To join the forums you need to be logged in.

Click here to register your own account for free and I will personally explain to you how you can start getting your own fans and, making popdollars.
> Close
Helper
16 of the 24 stars earned

Forum

General < General First | Previous | Page: | Next | Last
Depiction of mental health in film/tv/novels
Private
Popstar



And american psycho, but again, murders are happening, not a good portrayal
Account deleted




December wrote:
Utdatert wrote:
Good Ones: 

- Even (bipolar disorder) in Skam

- Effy Stonem (psychosis,addiction and depression) in Skins

- Ian Gallagher (Bipolar disorder) Shameless (us) 

- Rue (addiciton and depression) Euphoria

- Noora (Anxiety) - Skam Norway

- Lauren Weil (PTSD) - Lauren Weil mini series


Bad ones:

- Girl Interrupted (main charachter cant remember her name) Borderline Personality disorder

- Silver Linings playbook (Bipolar disorder)

- 
i think many of the other characters are pretty accurate tho, but i mean i'm not an expert i guess.
after reading susanna kaysen's book, it's pretty accurate, but also a dramatisation, that proves the picture of how mental illness at the time period. the book was never intended to be a memoir or a biography, but rather an anthropologist view of mental illness (as said by susanna herself). 
honestly i feel like someone w bpd and other diagnosis', that it fits pretty well, all considering it has been altered to better be portrayed to the masses in cinema.
Private
Youtube Star



to me a good depiction is like . Possession lmfao
MissLondon
Queen of Queens



VP
InAllRetrospect
National Star



Utdatert wrote:
Good Ones: 

- Even (bipolar disorder) in Skam

- Effy Stonem (psychosis,addiction and depression) in Skins

- Ian Gallagher (Bipolar disorder) Shameless (us) 

- Rue (addiciton and depression) Euphoria

- Noora (Anxiety) - Skam Norway

- Lauren Weil (PTSD) - Lauren Weil mini series


Bad ones:

- Girl Interrupted (main charachter cant remember her name) Borderline Personality disorder

- Silver Linings playbook (Bipolar disorder)

- 

I really agree with the skins and shameless examples

Another bad one is the multiple personality disorder/DID from the movie Split, that one was reeeeeally bad. 
Private
Youtube Star



Utdatert wrote:
Good Ones: 

- Even (bipolar disorder) in Skam

- Effy Stonem (psychosis,addiction and depression) in Skins

- Ian Gallagher (Bipolar disorder) Shameless (us) 

- Rue (addiciton and depression) Euphoria

- Noora (Anxiety) - Skam Norway

- Lauren Weil (PTSD) - Lauren Weil mini series


Bad ones:

- Girl Interrupted (main charachter cant remember her name) Borderline Personality disorder

- Silver Linings playbook (Bipolar disorder)

- 

really wouldnt consider effy a good depiction
Account deleted




and i loved the depiction of depression in "suicide room"
codepence n idolisation in "may"
psychosis in "black swan"
"jacob's ladder" is ripe w psychotic themes so that's that
December
World Famous



acidreflux wrote:
December wrote:
Utdatert wrote:
Good Ones: 

- Even (bipolar disorder) in Skam

- Effy Stonem (psychosis,addiction and depression) in Skins

- Ian Gallagher (Bipolar disorder) Shameless (us) 

- Rue (addiciton and depression) Euphoria

- Noora (Anxiety) - Skam Norway

- Lauren Weil (PTSD) - Lauren Weil mini series


Bad ones:

- Girl Interrupted (main charachter cant remember her name) Borderline Personality disorder

- Silver Linings playbook (Bipolar disorder)

- 
i think many of the other characters are pretty accurate tho, but i mean i'm not an expert i guess.
after reading susanna kaysen's book, it's pretty accurate, but also a dramatisation, that proves the picture of how mental illness at the time period. the book was never intended to be a memoir or a biography, but rather an anthropologist view of mental illness (as said by susanna herself). 
honestly i feel like someone w bpd and other diagnosis', that it fits pretty well, all considering it has been altered to better be portrayed to the masses in cinema.
yeah exactly! movies are never 100% accurate, it has to be attractive and interesting to watch. i think it's kinda accurate for being a movie honestly. especially the minor characters in the movie, like daisy, polly.
Private
Youtube Star



girl interrupted is a bad one imo

i have very conflicted feelings about split, obviously the "person with DID is a murderer and a monster" thing is very very bad but i feel like the actual performance when it comes to the alters and switches is kinda good? idk, all the stigmatizing stuff is really bad but some parts of it seem very realistic/accurate imo. at least to my own limited experience
Private
Popstar



acidreflux wrote:
and i loved the depiction of depression in "suicide room"
codepence n idolisation in "may"
psychosis in "black swan"
"jacob's ladder" is ripe w psychotic themes so that's that
Suicide room is an amazing movie ouff 
December
World Famous



i remember watching the movie sybil in school a few years ago when we worked with DID/MPD, and i thought it was soooo good, UNTIL i learnt more about DID and realized it was not very good at all...it was too dramatic
Private
Popstar



Limbs wrote:
girl interrupted is a bad one imo

i have very conflicted feelings about split, obviously the "person with DID is a murderer and a monster" thing is very very bad but i feel like the actual performance when it comes to the alters and switches is kinda good? idk, all the stigmatizing stuff is really bad but some parts of it seem very realistic/accurate imo. at least to my own limited experience
Yeah I think the problem is just did being portrayed as something scary and dangerous I think, when ppl with it are neither
Persona
Streetmusician



Delusion1111111 wrote:
to me a good depiction is like . Possession lmfao
yes, I like when films go down a more metaphorical route with it. Melancholia is more of a 'controversial~' depiction lol but i like the idea of 'depression is basically a massive planet crashing into earth and killing everyone'. Tarkovsky's The Sacrifice is kind of like that to

also i like that it doesn't try to make anyone into saints/martyrs which i find a lot with mental health depiction 
MissLondon
Queen of Queens



Frankie & Alice
The 3 Faces of Eve and Sybil
Private
National Star



(spoilers for the dark tower books)

idk of any good ones, but as for bad ones, susannah from the dark tower books was incredibly disappointing because she STARTED out as a good depiction of DID (dissociation from a traumatic incident from her childhood, her alters only presenting in triggering situations, etc) but then stephen king remembered that he was actually a shitty author and 1. made one of her "alters" secretly a demon that was possessing her, 2. had her ~*magically cured*~ when she went through the doorway to the other world.
Post comment
Post Comment
To load new posts: activated
First | Previous | Page: | Next | Last